Federal Circuits, 4th Cir. (August 10, 1993)
Docket number: 92-5292
Permanent Link:
http://vlex.com/vid/anthony-christopher-christian-leroy-36056689
Id. vLex: VLEX-36056689
Click here to download this article in graphic format (Acrobat Reader)

Appeal from the United States District Court for the Middle District of North Carolina, at Winston-Salem. William L. Osteen, Sr., District Judge. (CR-91-230-WS)
Michael Andrew Grace, Greeson, Grace & Gatto, P.A., Winston-Salem, North Carolina, for Appellant.Robert Michael Hamilton, Assistant United States Attorney, Greensboro, North Carolina, for Appellee.Lisa S. Costner, Greeson, Grace & Gatto, P.A., Winston-Salem, North Carolina, for Appellant.Robert H. Edmunds, Jr., United States Attorney, Greensboro, North Carolina, for Appellee.M.D.N.C.AFFIRMED.Before HALL and MURNAGHAN, Circuit Judges, and G. Ross ANDERSON, Jr., United States District Judge for the District of South Carolina, sitting by designation.OPINIONPER CURIAM:The defendant pled guilty to several charges involving crack cocaine and a firearm. The defendant now appeals the trial judge's decision upholding the validity of a search warrant and the application of certain sentencing guidelines. We find no error and therefore affirm the judgment of the district court.I.On August 24, 1991, vice officers of the Winston-Salem Police Department set up surveillance at 2616 Windy Crossing Drive and 2826 Windy Crossing Drive in Winston-Salem, North Carolina. At approximately 9:50 p.m., Officer Jason Swaim observed a black male and black female leave a residence at 2616 Windy Crossing. The officer saw them get into a white car and drive away. Officers followed the car until it reached another residence at 2826 Windy Crossing.Officer Connie Southern was in position to observe 2826 Windy Crossing. She observed a white car pull up in front of the residence. A black male and a black female got out of the car and entered the residence. About ten minutes later, the couple left the residence, got back in the car, and left the area.At about 10:05, Officer Swaim then observed the same couple return to the residence at 2616 Windy Crossing. The couple went to the front porch. The man then went around to the side of the house and appeared to place something in the pine needles. Officer Swaim then observed this person go to the rear of the residence and again place something in the pine needles. This second spot was near the deck at the rear of the residence. This person then returned to the front porch and went inside. Approximately one hour later, the same couple left the residence and drove away in a grey Mercury Cougar.Later that evening, the officers obtained a search warrant for 2616 Windy Crossing.1 Officer Swaim assisted in the search of the exterior of 2616 Windy Crossing. He searched the areas where he had previously observed the person placing items in the pine needles. He found rocks of cocaine, razor blades, and nine millimeter ammunition. Inside the house, the officers found a bottle of mannitol which tested positive for cocaine. Mannitol is commonly used to cut down the strength of powder cocaine.The officers then obtained a search warrant for 2826 Windy Crossing. This warrant was based on the observation of a person apparently hiding things immediately after returning from 2826 Windy Crossing. Various items were seized in the ensuing search including crack cocaine and a nine millimeter handgun. The officers then arrested four people, including the defendant.On October 29, 1991, a federal grand jury in the Middle District of North Carolina issued a four count indictment against the four defendants. The first count charged that Christian and others conspired to possess and to distribute more than 50 grams of cocaine base. The second and third counts charged that on two different occasions Christian and one or more of the other defendants possessed with intent to distribute more than 50 grams of cocaine base. The fourth count charged that Christian carried and used a firearm in connection with a drug trafficking crime.On December 30, 1991, the grand jury handed down a superseding indictment. This new indictment added an additional count of using a firearm in connection with a drug trafficking offense. The new charge was added as count two with the remaining counts being renumbered. The district judge subsequently dismissed this count.Christian filed a motion to suppress the fruits of the search of 2826 Windy Crossing. The district court found that the search warrant was issued in good faith and refused to suppress evidence obtained during the search.On January 23, 1992, Christian and his co-defendants went on trial before a jury. One of the co-defendants, Tonya McMoore, testified for the Government. She testified that she had been the girlfriend of Anthony Christian. She described how she assisted Christian in selling narcotics. Her testimony was that in late May, 1991, she, Christian, and Raymond Anderson flew to New York to obtain drugs. The airline they used was U.S. Air. After obtaining a quantity of crack cocaine, the trio returned to North Carolina by bus. She testified that they carried the crack cocaine in an aqua colored overnight bag. This bag was purchased at a J.C. Penny's in Winston-Salem. McMoore further testified that the trio left the bus in Greensboro because the police entered the bus. According to the testimony, McMoore and Christian left Raymond Anderson with the bag. He later showed up back in Winston-Salem but without the crack cocaine which had been confiscated by the police. During the Government's case in chief, Christian changed his plea to guilty as to Counts One, Three, Four, and Five.Prior to his sentencing, Christian objected to the presentence report made by the United States Probation Office. The objections were to the four level increase for a leadership role in the offense, to the denial of a two level decrease for acceptance of responsibility, and to the amount of drugs for which he was held accountable.Christian's objections were overruled. The district court sentenced him to 370 months on Counts One, Three, and Four. The court further sentenced Christian to five years on Count Five, to run consecutively to the first sentence.This appeal followed.II.We review the factual findings of the trial court for clear error while the legal conclusions based on these factual findings are reviewed de novo. United States v. Ramapuram, 632 F.2d 1149, 1155 (4th Cir. 1980), cert. denied,Try vLex for FREE for 3 days
Access legal information from United States including:
Try vLex without any commitment for 3 days and see why you need it.
3
days of Free Access