Federal Circuits, Fed. Cir. (December 26, 1996)
Docket number: 95-5067
Permanent Link:
http://vlex.com/vid/citable-nonprecedential-ruth-ann-worman-36122292
Id. vLex: VLEX-36122292
Click here to download this article in graphic format (Acrobat Reader)

Before MICHEL, CLEVENGER, and BRYSON, Circuit Judges.
CLEVENGER, Circuit Judge.The United States (government) appeals from the judgment of the United States Court of Federal Claims, Worman v. United States, No. 92-475C (Fed.Cl. Jan. 9, 1995), holding that the government's actions with respect to the property of Ruth Ann Worman and Howard S. Worman (the Wormans) constituted a taking under the Fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution and awarding just compensation. Because the government's actions did not constitute a taking for which such compensation is required, we reverse.* In 1989, Mr. Worman accepted employment as an aircraft mechanic in the United States Virgin Islands and the Wormans arranged with the Tropical Shipping Company (Tropical Shipping) to ship four crates of personal property from New Jersey to the Virgin Islands. The property consisted of tools that Mr. Worman needed for his employment and a handgun owned by Mrs. Worman.The property arrived in the Virgin Islands on or about September 15, 1989, where it was taken to a warehouse owned by Tropical Shipping for inspection by the United States Customs Service (Customs). In the course of examining the property, Customs found the handgun and, using a computer tracking system, determined preliminarily that the handgun was stolen. Customs directed Tropical Shipping not to release the entire shipment, including the aircraft tools, until the status of the handgun could be finally determined.On September 17, 1989, while the property remained in the warehouse, Hurricane Hugo visited the Virgin Islands and damaged the warehouse. On September 30, 1989, Customs authorized Tropical Shipping to release all of the Wormans' property save the handgun. On the same day, Mr. Worman arrived at the warehouse to claim his property, but found substantially all of the contents of the four crates gone.On May 4, 1990, Mr. Worman filed an administrative claim against Customs for $61,405.69 for the loss of his tools. Citing the exemption to the Federal Tort Claims Act (FTCA) for Customs' actions, 28 U.S.C. 2680(c) (1994), Customs denied this claim on December 18, 1990. Subsequently, the Wormans sued Customs in the United States District Court for the District of New Jersey on tort and implied contract theories. Because of the exemption for Customs in the FTCA and because the implied contract claim could only be heard in the Court of Federal Claims,1 the District Court dismissed the complaint with prejudice to the extent that it alleged claims under the FTCA and transferred the case to the Court of Federal Claims.Acting sua sponte, the Court of Federal Claims added a claim that the government took the Wormans' property without just compensation in violation of the Fifth Amendment. After a trial held in October 1993, the Court of Federal Claims issued a decision on the implied contract and takings claims on September 16, 1994. As to the implied contract claim, the Court of Federal Claims ruled for the government because the Wormans had failed to establish the existence of an implied contract. As to the takings claim, the Court of Federal Claims found as matters of fact that Hurricane Hugo, security problems at the Tropical Shipping warehouse, and looting were not the cause of the Wormans' loss. Instead, the Court of Federal Claims found that Customs' detention of the Wormans' property for a public purpose caused the Wormans' loss. Because Customs failed to follow its own procedures in securing the Wormans' goods, the Court of Federal Claims held that the government committed a taking. After the Court of Federal Claims set the amount of damages at $66,333.09 plus interest, the government appealed to this court.2IIWe review findings of fact made by the Court of Federal Claims for clear error. Whitney Benefits, Inc. v. United States, 926 F.2d 1169, 1171 (Fed.Cir.), cert. denied,Try vLex for FREE for 3 days
Access legal information from United States including:
Try vLex without any commitment for 3 days and see why you need it.
3
days of Free Access