Federal Circuits, 8th Cir. (March 24, 1969)
Docket number: 19176
Permanent Link:
http://vlex.com/vid/dan-lee-white-united-states-america-36732697
Id. vLex: VLEX-36732697
Click here to download this article in graphic format (Acrobat Reader)

Lawrence LeTourneau, of Jesse, LeTourneau & Johnston, Des Moines, Ia., for appellant, Dan Johnston, Des Moines, Ia., on the brief.
Claude H. Freeman, Asst. U. S. Atty., Des Moines, Ia., for appellee, James P. Rielly, U. S. Atty., and Jerry E. Williams, Asst. U. S. Atty., on the brief.Before VOGEL, LAY and BRIGHT, Circuit Judges.BRIGHT, Circuit Judge.Appellant Dan L. White was found guilty, after a jury trial, of willfully failing to comply with an order of his draft board directing him to report for and submit to induction into the armed forces of the United States, such refusal being in violation of § 12 of the Universal Military Training and Service Act, 50 U.S.C.App. § 462.1 He was sentenced to five years imprisonment and has appealed. We affirm the conviction.White first registered with his Des Moines local board in March of 1959. On July 24, 1964, his "student deferment" classification was changed to I-A making him available for military service. On September 2, 1966,2 the draft board mailed to White in New York3 an order requiring him to report for induction on October 3 at Fort Des Moines, Iowa. On September 10, White mailed the induction order back to the local board and wrote that he would not comply "without my legitimate right of appeal". Time for appeal from the 1964 I-A classification had expired and the local board so advised him.4 On September 18, White wrote to the local board requesting a special conscientious objector form SSS 150 and the local board mailed him this form approximately eight days later. White returned the completed form, stating his conscientious objector claim, to the local board on October 6. The board considered the claim at a meeting on October 28 and voted not to reopen his classification.5 Three days after the meeting, the following letter was mailed White:"October 31, 1966 TO Dan Lee White 1280 Walton Ave Apt 31 Bronx, 52, New York FROM Polk County Local Board No 13-128Please be advised that SSS Form 150, Conscientious Objector Form, was considered by the members of this Local Board at the October 28, 1966 meeting, and it was their unanimous opinion that the information presented did not merit reopening.Your Order to Report for Induction is hereby returned. Please report to the nearest draft board and request a transfer for Induction.BY DIRECTION OF THE LOCAL BOARDDorothy Adams, Clerk 13-128"White at no time reported for induction. He did write the board on December 19 saying in part: "I cannot in any manner partake in the Armed Forces".6 An indictment returned July 18, 1967, charged that, from October 3, 1966, up to and including the day of the indictment, White willfully and knowingly failed "to comply with an order of his local board to report for and submit to induction into the armed forces of the United States".In this appeal, White claims that the letter ordered him to do something other than report for induction; namely, to request a transfer for induction.7 A failure to request a transfer does not constitute a crime. Therefore, appellant reasons, the court should have entered a judgment of acquittal as a matter of law. Crucial to the resolution of this question is whether the order requiring White to report for induction on October 3 required him to act subsequent to that date.An induction order imposes a continuing duty on the registrant to submit to induction. United States v. Prince, 398 F.2d 686 (2nd Cir. 1968); Silverman v. United States, 220 F.2d 36 (8th Cir. 1955). This Court has said:"there was only one offense charged, that offense was failure to report for induction. By the Selective Service Regulations, § 1642.2, 32 C.F.R., it is made a continuing offense. No assault is made upon this regulation. The nature of the offense charged is such that it may upon proper proof be a continuing one." Silverman atTry vLex for FREE for 3 days
Access legal information from United States including:
Try vLex without any commitment for 3 days and see why you need it.
3
days of Free Access