Supreme Court of Georgia, (June 13, 1977)
Docket number: 32344
ARGUED
HALL, Justice. - ARGUED
Permanent Link:
http://vlex.com/vid/fleming-v-the-state-20406012
Id. vLex: VLEX-20406012
Click here to download this article in graphic format (Acrobat Reader)
Judgment affirmed as to the conviction, vacated as to the sentence, and a new trial is ordered on the question of punishment. All the Justices concur, except Bowles, J., who concurs in the judgment, but dissents as to Division 6, and Jordan, J., who dissents.

U.S. Supreme Court - Barker v. Wingo, 407 U.S. 514 (1972)
Supreme Court of Georgia - BLAKE v. THE STATE., 239 Ga. 292, 236 S.E.2.d 637 (1977)
Supreme Court of Georgia - WARD v. THE STATE., 238 Ga. 367, 233 S.E.2.d 175 (1977)
Supreme Court of Georgia - CUNNINGHAM v. THE STATE., 235 Ga. 126, 218 S.E.2.d 854
Supreme Court of Georgia - COKER v. THE STATE (two cases)., 234 Ga. 555, 216 S.E.2.d 782 (1975)
Georgia Court Of Appeals - Hamilton v. The State., 166 Ga. App. 328, 304 S.E.2d 473 (1983)
Georgia Court Of Appeals - The State v. Lively., 155 Ga. App. 402, 270 S.E.2d 812 (1980)
Supreme Court of Georgia - TYLER v. THE STATE., 247 Ga. 119, 274 S.E.2.d 549 (1981)
Supreme Court of Georgia - MOORE v. KEMP., 254 Ga. 279, 328 S.E.2.d 725 (1985)
Supreme Court of Georgia - REDD v. THE STATE., 261 Ga. 300, 404 S.E.2.d 264 (1991)
Georgia Court Of Appeals - Bennett Et Al. v. The State., 153 Ga. App. 21, 264 S.E.2d 516 (1979)
Supreme Court of Georgia - JARRELL v. ZANT., 248 Ga. 492, 284 S.E.2.d 17
Supreme Court of Georgia - GRIGGS v. THE STATE., 241 Ga. 317, 245 S.E.2.d 269 (1978)
Supreme Court of Georgia - REDD v. THE STATE., 240 Ga. 753, 243 S.E.2.d 16 (1977)
Supreme Court of Georgia - CURTIS v. THE STATE., 243 Ga. 50, 252 S.E.2.d 614
Benjamin Zeesman, Edward Parrish, for appellant.
This is the direct appeal of the conviction and death sentence of Son H. Fleming, who was convicted of the murder of Police Chief James Giddens of Ray City, Berrien County.The state presented evidence from which the jury was entitled to find the following:Appellant borrowed a red and white Ford car from a friend on February 11, 1976. Around 10 or 10:30 p.m. that day a grocery store in Adel (Cook County) was robbed by two black males identified as Larry Fleming (appellant's nephew) and Henry Willis. One robber was armed with a nickel-plated .22 caliber gun. The stolen money was stuffed in a paper sack, and a carton of Kool cigarettes was also stolen.The red and white Ford (apparently occupied by two black males) passed through Ray City shortly after the robbery, and aroused the suspicion of Chief Giddens, who had heard of the robbery over his radio. Chief Giddens pursued the car, and reported a description (including the license plate number) of it by radio. Minutes later Giddens' police car was found abandoned by a friend with whom he had been talking prior to the pursuit. Giddens' disappearance was reported, and at 12:30 a.m. the red and white car was stopped; its three black male occupants (appellant, his nephew, and Willis) were arrested. Giddens' .357 magnum pistol, a nickel-plated .22 revolver, a brown sack of money, and a carton of Kool cigarettes were found in the car.Giddens' body was found in a pond in Lanier County. He had been shot several times. Powder burns and the patterns of ratshot from the .22 pistol indicated that some of the wounds were made at a range of less than 18 inches. One bullet recovered from the body was fired from Giddens' gun.After his arrest appellant made a number of statements. He initially stated that his nephew and Willis had borrowed the car from him before the robbery, and that he did not see them again until they picked him up shortly before the arrest.His next statement indicated that he had been picked up after the robbery, but before the pursuit by Chief Giddens. He stated that the three of them were stopped by Giddens, and when the policeman attempted to search the car he was overpowered and abducted by the other two. Appellant claimed that he was forced to drive the car while his nephew and Willis held Giddens at gunpoint. After Giddens told them of his report of the license number of the car, they drove to a remote area and let him out. When Giddens ran in an attempt to escape, both Larry Fleming and Willis shot at him. Giddens fell wounded into the nearby lake; Larry Fleming and Willis followed him there. Appellant heard additional shots. This statement also indicated that appellant begged the other two not to kill Giddens, and that he acted only out of fear of them.The testimony of a fellow inmate at the Cook County Jail indicated that appellant admitted driving the car while the others robbed the store, and that it was appellant who first shot at Giddens as he ran. At all times appellant has denied having shot Giddens as he stood helpless in the water. Appellant denied making this last statement to the fellow inmate.Appellant's only evidence in defense was his own testimony, in which he returned to his first story. In the sentencing phase his counsel presented no additional evidence of mitigating circumstances, relying on the evidence at the guilt phase. Appellant's personal history sheet shows no convictions for serious or violent crimes, and a long history of employment (more than twenty years) in various jobs. He was 46 at the time of the murder.1. Appellant was arrested on the morning after the murder, February 12, 1976, and tried beginning on January 24, 1977. The delay was caused in part by the infrequency of the terms of court in Lanier County, which are held only twice a year, in January and September. Another factor in the delay was a request for a continuance by defense counsel. No demand for trial was made.Appellant asserts that the delay alone entitled him to a discharge for denial of a speedy trial. This is not the law. Barker v. Wingo, 407 U. S. 514, 523 (1972); Bryant v. State,Try vLex for FREE for 3 days
Access legal information from United States including:
Try vLex without any commitment for 3 days and see why you need it.
3
days of Free Access