La imparcialidad: mito del legislador racional

AuthorAmanda González Hernández
PositionEstudiante de 4to año de la carrera de Derecho Alumna ayudante del Departamento de Derecho Civil y Familia Facultad de Derecho Universidad de La Habana
Pages280-301
CUBALEX  / 
La imparcialidad: mito del legislador racional
AMANDA GONZÁLEZ HERNÁNDEZ*
CUBA
Sumario

 


 
         

 
 
Resumen



 



Palabras clave

Abstract
Impartiality, as an organic principle of jurisdiction seeks to create the ideal situa-
tion about manifestation of justice and legal security, to condition a state of reliability
that is needed in the individuals who come to it, in pursuit of subjection to the judicial
* 

CUBALEX
Amanda González Hernández
 / 
system. However, the legislative request goes beyond the frames of objectivity and rationality,
due to the existence of elements inherent in our human condition that make it impossible
for us to value the existence of the other as alien to our subjectivity, increasing the diculty
of judicial work.
Keywords
Impartiality, judges, conict resolution, human subjectivity.
Exordio





   
  
        
          


      

       


  
    
    

 

 Introducción al estudio del proceso civil
         

     

  
El ser y la nada,
CUBALEX
La imparcialidad: mito del legislador racional
 / 
ser


    



 

       






la naturaleza humana y la libertad
son inseparables desde un principio. La noción de libertad se emplea aquí no en el sentido
positivo de “libertad para”, sino en el sentido negativo de “libertad de”, es decir, liberación
de la determinación instintiva del obrar4




     

La justicia se basa en la imparcialidad de las personas que intervienen legalmente
en la resolución de la causa. Excepto las partes en sentido material, respecto a las cuales la
parcialidad es condición esencial, todas las demás personas deben ser tan imparciales como
sea posible y en razón directa de su inuencia legal sobre el contenido de la resolución.5 



 ,    
 
 
 Tesis sobre Feuerbach
4 El miedo a la libertad
5           

CUBALEX
Amanda González Hernández
 / 





     
     
     

  


         
      





 

  














    
   

  La condición postmoderna
CUBALEX
La imparcialidad: mito del legislador racional
 / 
1. La imparcialidad: denición, alcance y manifestación
práctica. Superación del mito del juez objetivo
  
7

   

         
         
     


   

       
       
      
   
   

    
    
   
       









  

7   

      

CUBALEX
Amanda González Hernández
 / 


    
9

 



     


       


      






         

   
    
 


 




  racionalidad    
 Estudios de Derecho Procesal Civil,  
 

 Elogio de los Jueces 

CUBALEX
La imparcialidad: mito del legislador racional
 / 



   
        

     



   




   
  
   


        


  
     
. Todas ellas, presentan una serie de
características que dan la posibilidad de su uso como cuasi-sinónimos.13 
    
   

 




        



 
Revista Española de Derecho Administrativo
CUBALEX
Amanda González Hernández
 / 


     
   
 
     

    

  






 
 16





  Delimitación conceptual del principio de objetividad: objeti-
vidad, neutralidad e imparcialidad  Documentación Administrativa   

 
 

  

   


objetivasimparcialidad 


 




Documentación
Administrativa
CUBALEX
La imparcialidad: mito del legislador racional
 / 
   
  

   





 
     



  
 







   

      
        

         


             
              



  Derecho a la imparcialidad judicial   
        
 Revista Europea de Derechos Fundamentales   


CUBALEX
Amanda González Hernández
 / 
1.1. La decisión judicial como resultado de un proceso formal, inte-
lectual y volitivo
 

 
   
    





      



 
declararán solemnemente en sesión pública, que ejercerán sus atribuciones con toda impar-
cialidad y conciencia18

  
   
         
 
   

urge advertir que la antítesis de legislación y jurisdicción, esto es, de creación
y aplicación del Derecho, no es absoluta sino relativa19

         

          


 Teoría general del Estado, 
              
   
  
   
 al igual que se han hecho
anticuadas las tesis que sostienen la naturaleza mecánica, pasiva y no creativa de la actividad judicial
CUBALEX
La imparcialidad: mito del legislador racional
 / 





 
 


  
    
     

 







          



    

 La jurisprudencia, interpretación y creación del Derecho (serie de conferencias). 

     
 

         
       
    
        
      




La motivación como sustento de la sentencia
objetiva y materialmente justa, 
CUBALEX
Amanda González Hernández
 / 





 
       
      



     



    

   
  





      
      
     
 
   
  

  
  
        
        
  
  
    
        

 consultados el 10/04/2017 a las 19:17 pm.
CUBALEX
La imparcialidad: mito del legislador racional
 / 
             








1.1.2. Relación con el principio de Independencia. Valoraciones




 



  







 

 
       
     
   
 Derecho Procesal, Parte General, Félix Varela,
     
 

           

 La Europa de los Derechos. El Convenio Europeo de Derechos
Humanos
CUBALEX
Amanda González Hernández
 / 
   


      


      








     




      
     

     
   


   
   



    



   
  
 
CUBALEX
La imparcialidad: mito del legislador racional
 / 
       



    
         dependen-
cia




   

  



   



     
 
       

 




 


      
        
    31 
 Fundamentos… cit.
 International Arbitration. Law and Practice

CUBALEX
Amanda González Hernández
 / 

      
  
      





   




1.2. La imparcialidad como aspiración del sistema de justicia.
Su conguración como garantía de una tutela judicial efectiva
        

     
      
 





  
    
        

      
 

    


 

  

CUBALEX
La imparcialidad: mito del legislador racional
 / 


   







  
















 



   
    

   

 
          
 



CUBALEX
Amanda González Hernández
 / 
2. La imparcialidad en el arbitraje
 
    


   







   



   

 
Sixty Years of Arbitration Practice

 Corte Inter-
nacional de Arbitraje de ParísTodo árbitro debe ser y permanecer independien-
te de las partes en el arbitrajeConvención de Washington

Las personas designadas para figurar en las listas deben gozar de amplia conside-
ración moral, tener reconocida competencia en el campo del derecho, del comercio, de la industria o de las
finanzas, e inspirar plena confianza en su imparcialidad de juicio”. 
Ley Modelo sobre Arbitraje Comercial Internacional  
La persona propuesta como
árbitro deberá revelar a quienes hagan averiguaciones en relación con su posible nombramiento, todas las
circunstancias que puedan dar lugar a dudas justificadas acerca de su imparcialidad o independencia. Una
vez nombrado o elegido, el árbitro revelará tales circunstancias a las partes, a menos que ya les haya infor-
mado de ellasAmerican
Arbitration AssociationLos árbitros que actúen bajo estas reglas serán imparciales
e independientes. Antes de aceptar el nombramiento, la persona propuesta como árbitro informará a la
administradora sobre cualquier circunstancia que pudiera dar lugar a dudas justificadas con respecto a su
imparcialidad o independencia. Si, en cualquier etapa del arbitraje, surgieran nuevas circunstancias que
pudieran dar lugar a tales dudas, el árbitro informará a la brevedad tales circunstancias a las partes y a
la administradora. Al recibo de tal información dada por el árbitro o por una parte, la administradora la
comunicará a las otras partes y al Tribunal Reglamento de Arbitraje de la Corte de
Arbitraje Internacional de LondresLondon Court of International Arbitration
CUBALEX
La imparcialidad: mito del legislador racional
 / 

 






    
    London Court of International Arbitration (LCIA





    

   
   
          
   







          
Todos los árbitros que instruyan un arbitraje al amparo de este Reglamento serán y se mantendrán en
todo momento imparciales e independientes de las partes, absteniéndose de actuar como abogados de éstas.
Ningún árbitro, antes o después de su nombramiento, informará a las partes del fondo de la controversia o
de su eventual resultado
       cuando las partes tienen distintas nacionalidades, un solo
árbitro o el presidente del tribunal arbitral no debe tener la misma nacionalidad de cualquier parte, salvo
que las partes que no sean de la misma nacionalidad acuerden todas por escrito lo contrario
LC IA, Arbitration Rules
 

CUBALEX
Amanda González Hernández
 / 
      

  

 

 

   


 
 



        


 
       

   
    
 
        




  
    Rivista dell´arbitrato  

 
      El
nombramiento de árbitros deberá hacerse con el consentimiento unánime de todas las partes interesadas en el
litigio sometido a su decision
 

  
  

CUBALEX
La imparcialidad: mito del legislador racional
 / 
  


   


         
 

 
  
      
      

3. Conclusiones








 







          
     
         
   
    

      

CUBALEX
Amanda González Hernández
 / 





   
        
  

        







      


VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT