John Yama for himself and Customary representatives for Lukas Berem, Bepi, Eka, John Nabuta and Joy Sent v Mathew Minok, Police Commander, Peter Agilo, Police Commissioner and The Independent State of Papua New Guinea (2002) N2198
Jurisdiction | Papua New Guinea |
Judge | Kapi DCJ |
Judgment Date | 17 May 2002 |
Court | National Court |
Citation | (2002) N2198 |
Year | 2002 |
Judgement Number | N2198 |
Full Title: John Yama for himself and Customary representatives for Lukas Berem, Bepi, Eka, John Nabuta and Joy Sent v Mathew Minok, Police Commander, Peter Agilo, Police Commissioner and The Independent State of Papua New Guinea (2002) N2198
National Court: Kapi DCJ
Judgment Delivered: 17 May 2002
N2198
PAPUA NEW GUINEA
[In the National Court of Justice at Mt. Hagen]
WS. No. 266 of 1998
BETWEEN:
John Yama for himself and
Customary representatives for
Lukas Berem, Bepi, Eka, John Nabuta and Joy Sent
Plaintiff
AND:
Mathew Minok, Police Commander
First Defendant
AND:
Peter Agilo, Police Commissioner
Second Defendant
AND:
The Independent State of
Papua New Guinea
Third Defendant
Mt. Hagen: Kapi DCJ
13th & 17th May 2002
DAMAGES – Exemplary damages – Discretion to award – circumstances when exemplary damages may be awarded.
Cases cited:
David Wali Kofewi v The State [1983] PNGLR 449
Abel Tomba v The State [Unreported judgment of the Supreme Court dated 7th April 1997, SC 578).
Andale More and Manis Andale v Henry Tokam and The State (Unreported judgment of the National Court dated 26 September 1997
Legislation referred to:
Wrongs (Miscellaneous Provision) Act (Ch. 297)
Claims By and Against the State Act 1986.
P. Dowa for the plaintiff
B. Ovia for the defendants
17th May 2002
Kapi DCJ: The plaintiff sued the defendants for damages arising out of a police shooting of the deceased Noki Yama at Togoba near Mt Hagen. The claim is brought under the provisions of Wrongs (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act (Chapter 297).
Default judgment was entered for the plaintiff on 15th November 2000 and the matter came before me for assessment of damages.
The parties settled all heads of damages except the question of exemplary damages. For the purposes of this issue the parties agreed to the following facts. On the morning of 23rd June 1997 at about 10.30 am, the deceased Noki Yama was with her daughter waiting on the road to catch a PMV to come to Mt Hagen. While she was waiting, an unspecified number of police with Defence Force soldiers came by in police vehicles. The police started shooting at the crowd in the market nearby. A bullet hit the deceased and she died instantly. She fell on top of the daughter who received serious injuries. The claim for damages for personal injuries by the daughter is the subject of a separate cause of action. The deceased was not involved in any kind of wrong - doing. She was an innocent person waiting to catch a PMV on the road.
Counsel for the defendants submits that the State should not be liable to pay any exemplary damages on the basis that the actions of the police were completely outside the scope of their functions authorized by law. He relies on Andale More & Manis Andale v Henry Tokam & The State (Unreported judgment of the National Court dated 26th September 1997, N1641). That was a case in which the police were called into the area to negotiate peace amongst Mulyapin and Aiyakan clans both of the Tangula tribe. They were appropriately armed to quel any trouble that might arise. They talked with one of the clans without any incident. When the police came to the deceased’s territory, the policeman concerned saw it necessary to use the high powered gun against a group of men hiding on the ridges on the watch for their enemy clansmen and guarding the territory. In so doing he shot the deceased.
The trial judge discussed the law as set out in the Supreme Court case of Abel Tomba v The State (Unreported judgment of the Supreme Court dated 7th April 1997, SC 578) and David Wali Kofewi v The State [1983] PNGLR 449. He also referred to s 1 (4) of the Wrongs (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act. Applying these principles, he concluded that it was not necessary for the policeman to fire the gun and that he was not authorized to do so by law. Consequently he refused to make an award for exemplary damages in the exercise of his...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Luke Deukari v Danny Kuglam and The Independent State of Papua New Guinea (2006) N3087
...Huaimbukie v James Baugen and The State (2004) N2589; Jerry Goria v Sergeant Jeffery Simera and Others (2001) N2066; John Yama v The State (2002) N2198; Jonathan Mangope Paraia v The State (1995) N1343; Kinsim Business Group v Joseph Hompwafi and Others (1997) N1634; Kolaip Palapi and Other......
-
Desmond Huaimbukie, Marcus Huaimbukie, Stanis Wafi Mairangian, Patrick Saihira, Hubert Makes, Malaki Yenu, Elphin Yenu and Saihengui Harinduo v James Baugen as Station Commander of Yangoru Rural Police Station and The Independent State of Papua New Guinea (2004) N2589
...(2002) N2289, Peter Aigilo v The Independent State of Papua New Guinea (2001) N2102, John Yama v The Independent State of Papua New Guinea (2002) N2198, Kolaip Palapi v Independent State of Papua New Guinea (2001) N2274, The Independent State of Papua New Guinea v Kofowei [1987] PNGLR 5, Ab......
-
Palme Tunn v The Independent State of Papua New Guinea (2006) N2973
...Huaimbukie v James Baugen and The State (2004) N2589 Jerry Goria v Sergeant Jeffery Simera and Others (2001) N2066 John Yama v The State (2002) N2198 Jonathan Mangope Paraia v The State (1995) N1343 Kembo Tirima v ANGAU Memorial Hospital Board and The State (2005) N2779 Kinsim Business Grou......
-
Philip Kunnga v The Independent State of Papua New Guinea (2005) N2864
...Lanyat and Another v The State [1997] PNGLR 253, Jerry Goria v Sergeant Jeffery Simera and Others (2001) N2066, John Yama v The State (2002) N2198, Kembo Tirima v ANGAU Memorial Hospital Board and The State (2005) N2779, Kinsim Business Group v Joseph Hompwafi and Others (1997) N1634, Nogo ......
-
Luke Deukari v Danny Kuglam and The Independent State of Papua New Guinea (2006) N3087
...Huaimbukie v James Baugen and The State (2004) N2589; Jerry Goria v Sergeant Jeffery Simera and Others (2001) N2066; John Yama v The State (2002) N2198; Jonathan Mangope Paraia v The State (1995) N1343; Kinsim Business Group v Joseph Hompwafi and Others (1997) N1634; Kolaip Palapi and Other......
-
Desmond Huaimbukie, Marcus Huaimbukie, Stanis Wafi Mairangian, Patrick Saihira, Hubert Makes, Malaki Yenu, Elphin Yenu and Saihengui Harinduo v James Baugen as Station Commander of Yangoru Rural Police Station and The Independent State of Papua New Guinea (2004) N2589
...(2002) N2289, Peter Aigilo v The Independent State of Papua New Guinea (2001) N2102, John Yama v The Independent State of Papua New Guinea (2002) N2198, Kolaip Palapi v Independent State of Papua New Guinea (2001) N2274, The Independent State of Papua New Guinea v Kofowei [1987] PNGLR 5, Ab......
-
Palme Tunn v The Independent State of Papua New Guinea (2006) N2973
...Huaimbukie v James Baugen and The State (2004) N2589 Jerry Goria v Sergeant Jeffery Simera and Others (2001) N2066 John Yama v The State (2002) N2198 Jonathan Mangope Paraia v The State (1995) N1343 Kembo Tirima v ANGAU Memorial Hospital Board and The State (2005) N2779 Kinsim Business Grou......
-
Philip Kunnga v The Independent State of Papua New Guinea (2005) N2864
...Lanyat and Another v The State [1997] PNGLR 253, Jerry Goria v Sergeant Jeffery Simera and Others (2001) N2066, John Yama v The State (2002) N2198, Kembo Tirima v ANGAU Memorial Hospital Board and The State (2005) N2779, Kinsim Business Group v Joseph Hompwafi and Others (1997) N1634, Nogo ......