The State v Benjamin Nabate and Jeffery Jajata (2002) N2216
Jurisdiction | Papua New Guinea |
Judge | Jalina J |
Judgment Date | 18 April 2002 |
Court | National Court |
Citation | (2002) N2216 |
Year | 2002 |
Judgement Number | N2216 |
Full Title: The State v Benjamin Nabate and Jeffery Jajata (2002) N2216
National Court: Jalina J
Judgment Delivered: 18 April 2002
N2216
PAPUA NEW GUINEA
[In the National Court of Justice]
CR 1554/2001
CR 1555/2001
THE STATE
-V-
BENJAMIN NABATE
AND:
JEFFERY JAJATA
POPONDETTA : JALINA, J.
16TH & 18TH APRIL 2002
Criminal Law – Robbery – Sentence – Robbery of victim at dwelling house – No physical harm – Robbery of K538.00 cash and goods – Most goods recovered except for cash – Plea of guilty – First offenders –Prevalence of robberies – Custodial sentence necessary as deterrent – Criminal Code s.386 (2)
Ms. M. Boni for the State
Mr. P. N’dranoh for the Prisoners
18th April 2002
JALINA, J. These prisoners have pleaded guilty to one count of armed robbery of one John Gambo of cash and properties to the total value of K800.00 at Bongoho Compound on the night of 25th February 2001. Cash alone was in the sum of K538.00. Mr. Gambo was in his house on the night in question when he heard his dogs barking. When he opened the door to investigate he was met by the prisoners and their friends who were armed with a gun, a grass knife and a chain from a chainsaw. One of them flashed a torch in his eyes and then was threatened and forced back into the house. While one of them was guarding the victim at gunpoint the others searched the house and stole the items which have been referred to above including a radio with two speakers and 3 highlands bilums (string bags). They then escaped into the night.
The radio and highlands bilums have been returned but the K538.00 cash and some other items are yet to be recovered. No physical violence was employed against the victim. No properties were damaged.
The maximum penalty for armed robbery is life imprisonment under s.386 (2) of the Criminal Code Act subject to the Court’s discretion to impose a lesser sentence under s.19 of the Code. But the practice of the Court has been to impose a term of years. Hence the sentencing guidelines which were set by the Supreme Court in the well known case of Gimble –v- The State [1988 – 89] PNGLR 271. For the robbery of a dwelling house which was considered to be the most serious of all categories of robberies in view of the breach of a person’s Constitutional rights to privacy and to feel secure in his own home, the Supreme Court suggested a sentence of 7 years in a contested case and a lesser sentence in an uncontested case where there are no aggravating factors such as use of violence against the victims, the amount of money being large and discharge of firearm in the course of the robbery.
Relying on Gimble’s case and their personal antecedents together with other mitigating factors such as the absence of violence, the amount of money being small, their expression of remorse, this being their first offence and their plea of guilty, Defence Counsel, Mr. N’dranoh, has submitted that a more lenient sentence be imposed.
But the subsequent Supreme Court Decision in Don Hale –v- The State [1998] Unreported SC 564 has considered the decision in Gimble’s case to be 10 years out of date in view of the prevalence of violent crimes of armed robbery and the community’s concern over those crimes. I was one of the...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
The State v Gilbert James (2009) N3752
...2003 (2003); The State v Paul Maima Yogol (2004) N2583; The State v Tommy Yare & Anor, CR 1828 of 2003 (2004); The State v Benjamin Nabate (2002) N2216; The State v Allan Esri Waluta (2005) N2911; The State v Billy Bimaru (2000) N2025; The State v Vincent Malara (2002) N2188; The State v Ne......
-
The State v Kevin Aku Knox and Alex Ambi (2008) N3339
...Chris Banban & Anor (2004) N2645 The State v. Terence Ago (2004) N2673 The State v. Billy Bimaru (2000) N2025 The State v. Benjamin Nabate (2002) N2216 The State v. Allan Esri Waluta (2005) N2911 The State v. Lionel Paru, CR 749 of 2004 Hawai John v. The State, SCR 9 of 1995 (1998) John Aru......
-
The State v Austin Upena, Rodney Upena, Prichard Oresa and Osborne Upena (2002) N2222
...v Don Hale (1998) SC564, Tau Jim Anis v The State (2000) SC642, Gimble v The State [1988–89] PNGLR 271 and The State v Benjamin Nabate (2002) N2216 referred to ___________________________ Jalina J: These prisoners have pleaded guilty to one count of robbery of cash from Philip Hero and othe......
-
The State v Junior Robin Norai
...guilty and did not go into the house. He was a watchman;Plea of Guilty.8 years imposed.The State v Benjamin Nabata and Jeffrey Jajata (2002) N2216Prisoner in company; Plea of guilty;Gun, grass knife and chainsaw used;Stole K530 and personal properties;No physical violence was used against t......
-
The State v Gilbert James (2009) N3752
...2003 (2003); The State v Paul Maima Yogol (2004) N2583; The State v Tommy Yare & Anor, CR 1828 of 2003 (2004); The State v Benjamin Nabate (2002) N2216; The State v Allan Esri Waluta (2005) N2911; The State v Billy Bimaru (2000) N2025; The State v Vincent Malara (2002) N2188; The State v Ne......
-
The State v Kevin Aku Knox and Alex Ambi (2008) N3339
...Chris Banban & Anor (2004) N2645 The State v. Terence Ago (2004) N2673 The State v. Billy Bimaru (2000) N2025 The State v. Benjamin Nabate (2002) N2216 The State v. Allan Esri Waluta (2005) N2911 The State v. Lionel Paru, CR 749 of 2004 Hawai John v. The State, SCR 9 of 1995 (1998) John Aru......
-
The State v Austin Upena, Rodney Upena, Prichard Oresa and Osborne Upena (2002) N2222
...v Don Hale (1998) SC564, Tau Jim Anis v The State (2000) SC642, Gimble v The State [1988–89] PNGLR 271 and The State v Benjamin Nabate (2002) N2216 referred to ___________________________ Jalina J: These prisoners have pleaded guilty to one count of robbery of cash from Philip Hero and othe......
-
The State v Junior Robin Norai
...guilty and did not go into the house. He was a watchman;Plea of Guilty.8 years imposed.The State v Benjamin Nabata and Jeffrey Jajata (2002) N2216Prisoner in company; Plea of guilty;Gun, grass knife and chainsaw used;Stole K530 and personal properties;No physical violence was used against t......