Clyde Procure Alert: Too Good To Be True? 'Free' Contracts And Public Procurement

Contracting authorities are commonly offered pilots, trials or wholly "free of charge" goods, works or services. Contractors wishing to break into a new market, or expand their market share, often take a commercial view to undercut their competition.

The Public Contracts Regulations 2015 ("Regulations") and the public procurement directives, define a public contract as "contracts for pecuniary interest concluded in writing between one or more economic operators and one or more contracting authorities and having as their object the execution of works, the supply of products or the provision of services". It has always been clear that "pecuniary interest" has a wider application than simply cash payments in return for the goods, works or services.

A recent case from the Court of Justice of the European Union (C 606/17 IBA Molecular Italy Srl v Azienda ULSS n. 3 and others) has provided helpful guidance on the issue of how free of charge contracts are treated by the procurement rules.

The procurement was for medicinal products used radiological examinations. A private hospital (the Sacro Cuore) undertook to supply the medicinal product free of charge to nine regional public hospitals. The only payment under each contract was for the transport costs of a flat rate of EUR 180 per delivery.

The main supplier of the product in Italy challenged the lack of a procurement process to award the contracts to the Sacro Cuore.

At first instance the Italian Court dismissed IBA's claim on the basis that the products were supplied free of charge, and the delivery costs did not amount to "direct consideration". Following an appeal, the Italian Council of State recognised that this was not correct but held that the contract was exempt from the procurement regime because it amounted to a "public/public" contract to which the public procurement regime does not apply.

The CJEU disagreed and confirmed that:

  1. Sacro Cuore receives a "significant economic advantage" from a public authority under the arrangements;

  2. The "usual legal meaning of 'for pecuniary interest'" includes circumstances where each of the parties undertakes to...

To continue reading

Request your trial

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT