Electronic Signatures: Can You Automatically Enter Into A Binding Contract?

As technology advances, the law must keep up. For some time, parties have been able to sign or execute a contract and enter into a binding transaction by using an electronic form of signature. Many emails are also 'signed off' in this way or simply with a 'footer' which includes the name and details of the sender. To what extent are electronic signatures valid, such that a binding contract is entered into? In July 2019 the Law Commission of England and Wales issued guidance on the use of electronic signatures and the recent UK Court decision in Neocleous v Rees held that an email footer was sufficient to constitute a signature and create a binding contract.

More than a signature

It is worthwhile bearing in mind the fundamental elements of a contract. It has long been established that there are three elements required to create a valid, binding contract under the common law: offer and acceptance, consideration and an intention to create binding legal relations. When it comes to acceptance of the other party's offer, the law has established a number of rules. For example, acceptance of the offer must be communicated to the other party. Equally sensibly, silence cannot constitute acceptance.

The July 2019 Law Commission Report on Electronic execution of documents confirms that these elements must be present - it is not just the execution of the contract, whether in writing or electronically, which is relevant. Critically, the Report refers to 'intention' in relation to electronic signatures. It states that in determining whether the method of signature demonstrates a party's intention to enter a binding contract, the courts will adopt an objective approach considering all the surrounding circumstances.

Validity of electronic execution

The Report recognises that the UK legal system must be flexible and that contracts can be created in many ways. Some contracts may not need to be executed in any particular way, while other documents, such as deeds, need to be witnessed and signed in a certain way in order to be valid. Most construction contracts, consultant appointments and collateral warranties entered into in relation to a construction contract are executed as deeds.

In summary, the Law Commission Report concludes that an electronic signature can be used to execute a document, including a deed, provided that:

The person signing the document intends to authenticate (or enter into) the document; and Any other formalities required to validly...

To continue reading

Request your trial

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT