Money Up Front: The Operation Of Advance Payment Clauses

Advance payment provisions are used in construction contracts to assist the contractor, i.e. so that the contractor does not have to fund the works out of its own money. A question which arose in a recent case is: can a contractor terminate the contract, and sue for an advance payment which ought to have been paid, even if the contractor has not done any work?

Failure to make an advance payment required under a construction contract can give rise to unusual risks and opportunities. In Mirimskaya v Evans the TCC clarified that a failure to pay an advance instalment (where a contract requires advance payment) can give a contractor the right to terminate, stop work, and sue for the advance payment that should have been made. The contractor in that case sued for payment of an agreed advance payment. This followed the owner having repudiated the contract, and the contractor electing to terminate without having performed any of the relevant work.

Obtaining advance payment after work has stopped would in most cases over-compensate a contractor. If the contractor has not begun any of the work relating to the advance payment, then a legal rule known as "total failure of consideration" will prevent a contractor from recovering the advance payment. However, Mirimskaya v Evans suggests that if a contractor has performed some work relating to an advance payment (even if only a small portion), it may recover all of the advance payment. For example, a contractor involved in a dispute over advanced payments might perform 10% of work relating to an unpaid advance payment and then attempt to terminate and recover 100% of the advance payment.

There may be some scope for Mirmskaya v Evans to be challenged at law. Until the law is clarified however there are a number of practical points be taken from the decision:

Parties involved in negotiations for advanced payments would be well advised to spell out an agreed position in the event of termination. One reasonable negotiating position might be for advance payments due post-termination to be reduced to reflect the actual amount of work done.

Advance payment bonds are sometimes provided by contractors to...

To continue reading

Request your trial

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT