The Ombudsman Commission, Ila Geno—Chief Ombudsman and Bernard Narokobi v The National Parliament, Ano Pala—Clerk of The National Parliament, The Honourable Bill Skate—Speaker of The National Parliament, Sir Albert Kipalan, The National Executive Council and The Right Honourable Michael Somare—Prime Minister (2003) SC721
| Jurisdiction | Papua New Guinea |
| Court | Supreme Court |
| Judge | Kapi CJ, Injia DCJ, Salika J, Jalina J, Sakora J |
| Judgment Date | 21 November 2003 |
| Citation | (2003) SC721 |
| Judgment Number | SC721 |
| Year | 2003 |
| Docket Number | SC OS No 2 of 2003 |
Full Title: SC OS No 2 of 2003; The Ombudsman Commission, Ila Geno—Chief Ombudsman and Bernard Narokobi v The National Parliament, Ano Pala—Clerk of The National Parliament, The Honourable Bill Skate—Speaker of The National Parliament, Sir Albert Kipalan, The National Executive Council and The Right Honourable Michael Somare—Prime Minister (2003) SC721
Supreme Court: Kapi CJ, Injia DCJ, Salika J, Jalina J, Sakora J
Judgment Delivered: 21 November 2003
SC721
[IN THE SUPREME COURT OF JUSTICE]
SC OS NO. 02 OF 2003
BETWEEN
THE OMBUDSMAN COMMISSION
-First Plaintiff-
AND:
ILA GENO- CHIEF OMBUDSMAN
-Second Plaintiff-
AND:
BERNARD NAROKOBI
-Third Plaintiff-
AND:
THE NATIONAL PARLIAMENT
-First Defendant-
AND:
ANO PALA, CLERK OF THE NATIONAL PARLIAMENT
-Second Defendant-
AND
THE HONOURABLE BILL SKATE, SPEAKER OF THE NATIONAL
PARLIAMENT
-Third Defendant-
SIR ALBERT KIPALAN
-Fourth Defendant-
AND:
THE NATIONAL EXECUTIVE COUNCIL
-Fifth Defendant-
AND:
THE RT HON MICHAEL SOMARE, PRIME MINISTER
-Sixth Defendant-
WAIGANI : KAPI CJ, INJIA DCJ, SALIKA, JALINA, SAKORA, JJ.
2003 : 5th, 6th, 21st November
Constitutional Law – National Parliament - Practice and Procedure- Election of Governor-General - Locus Standi – Originating Summons seeking Declaratory orders – Action by Ombudsman Commission and Chief Ombudsman and a private citizen – whether they have standing – Constitution S.18(1).
Constitutional Law – National Parliament – Nomination of Governor-General – Members of Parliament as proposer and a supporter of more than a candidate – Duties of Clerk of Parliament – Compliance with Constitutional Laws and Procedures – whether Clerk of Parliament has complied with such requirements - Organic Law ss.2,4,5,6,7, 8 and 9.
Constitutional Law – National Parliament - Interpretation and Application of Constitutional Laws – Election of Governor-General – Compliance with Constitutional Laws and Procedures – Whether election of Governor-General void – Organic Law ss.2,4,5,6,7,8 and 9.
CASES CITED:
SCR No. 4 of 1980; Re Petition of M.T. Somare [1981] PNGLR 265
The State v. Wik Kor [1983] PNGLR 24.
Counsel:
D. Cannings for the First and Second Plaintiffs.
C. Narokobi for the Third Plaintiff.
J. Nonggorr for the First Defendant.
S. Gabi for the Second Defendant.
A. Jerewai for the Third Defendant.
L. Henao for the Fourth Defendant.
J. Kumura for the Fifth and Sixth Defendants.
21st November, 2003
BY THE COURT: This is an originating process filed by way of originating summons seeking declaratory orders under s.18(1) of the Constitution. The background to this action may be described briefly as follows.
The Ombudsman Commission filed a Special Reference under s.19 of the Constitution (SCR No. 3 of 2003) on 3rd of October 2003. The reference raised seventeen (17) questions for the Supreme Court to give its advisory opinion. It is not necessary to set out the questions for the present purposes. The questions were referred on the basis of assumed facts. The reference was argued on Thursday 31st October and Friday 1st November.
On the 1st November, Mr Loani Henao, counsel for the Third Intervener (Sir Albert Kipalan), raised objection to the manner in which the reference was brought. His objection in essence was that while the reference was based on assumed facts, they resembled the real facts relating to the nomination of his client as Parliament’s nominee for appointment as Governor-General under the Constitution and the Organic Law on the Nomination of the Governor-General (Organic Law). He submitted that depending on the answers given to the questions referred, interested parties may file consequential cause of action against his client. To allow this to happen in this manner, he submitted, is to have multiplicity of proceedings constituting an abuse of the process of court as well as costly.
We did not hear full arguments on this issue. However, all the parties considering that there was some merit in the submission, agreed to adjourn the s 19 reference generally in order to give opportunity to any interested party to consider instituting an appropriate cause of action which would bring all issues of fact and constitutional law in the one proceeding.
After adjourning the special reference as agreed, the First and Second Plaintiffs filed this cause of action on Monday 3rd November. During the Directions hearing on the morning of 3rd November, Mr Bernard Narokobi sought to be joined as a plaintiff. As there was no objection to this application, the Court ordered Mr Bernard Narokobi to be joined as Third Plaintiff. The Defendants however, took issue with the locus standi of the First and Second Plaintiffs which we consider later.
It is helpful however to set out the undisputed facts which constitute the basis of the originating summons. On the 18th November 1997, the Queen as the Head of State appointed Sir Silas Atopare to be Governor-General of the Independent State of Papua New Guinea on and from the 20th November 1997. Under s.91 of the Constitution, the term of office is for a period of six (6) years. This term expired on the 19th of November 2003.
On 7th July 2003, the Acting Speaker of the National Parliament announced that the term of office of Sir Silas Atopare as Governor-General would expire on 19th November 2003 and that s.88(3) of the Constitution requires that the Speaker should call a meeting of the Parliament within the period of three months before the expiration of the term of the Governor-General. The Acting Speaker also called for nominations including any indication by the incumbent if he wishes to hold office for a second term.
During the period from about 10th to 18th September 2003 nine (9) forms of proposal for nomination of a person for appointment as Governor-General were submitted to the Clerk of the Parliament. This included an indication by Sir Silas Atopare seeking appointment for a second term.
On 12th September 2003, the Parliament resolved to meet at 2.00 pm on 18th September 2003 for the purpose of considering the nomination for appointment of the Governor-General.
The Parliament met on the 18th September with Speaker, the Hon. Bill Skate presiding. The Speaker informed the Parliament that Sir Silas Atopare had been proposed for a second term as Governor-General. The Member for Western Province then moved that the Parliament resolve that Sir Silas be approved for appointment for a second term. A ballot was conducted in accordance with s.87(5) of the Constitution and on the count of the votes, Sir Silas failed to muster the required two-thirds absolute majority.
The Speaker then informed the Parliament that the Clerk had furnished him a list of eight (8) candidates for nomination as Governor-General:
Sir Albert Kipalan
Sir Arnold Amet
Mr Bernard Narokobi
Mr Mathew Bendumb
Sir Pato Kakaraya
Sir Paulias Matane
Sir Thomas Kavali
Sir Tom Koraea
The voting was conducted in accordance with s.9 of the Organic Law. The results of the first ballot were as follows:
Sir Albert Kipalan 10
Sir Arnold Amet 14
Mt Bernard Narokobi 13
Mr`Mathew Bendumb 4
Sir Pato Kakaraya 12
Sir Paulias Matane 18
Sir Thomas Kavali 6
Sir Tom Koraea 3
Informal 2
The Speaker declared that Sir Tom Koraea be excluded from further ballot in accordance with s.9(3) of the Organic Law and proceeded to the second ballot. The results of the second ballot were as follows:
Sir Albert Kipalan 18
Sir Arnold Amet 20
Mr Bernard Narokobi 14
Mr Mathew Bendumb 2
Sir Pato Kakaraya 14
Sir Paulias Matane 17
Sir Thomas Kavali 5
The Speaker declared that Mr Mathew Bendumb be excluded from further ballot under s.9(3) of the Organic Law and proceeded to the third ballot. The results of the third ballot were as follows:
Sir Albert Kipalan 21
Sir Arnold Amet 18
Mr Bernard Narokobi 15
Sir Pato Kakaraya 13
Sir Paulias Matane 17
Sir Thomas Kavali 6
The Speaker declared that Sir Thomas Kavali be excluded from further ballot under s.9(3) of the Organic Law and proceeded to the fourth ballot. The results of the fourth ballot were as follows:
Sir Albert Kipalan 21
Sir Arnold Amet 19
Mr`Bernard Narokobi 15
Sit Pato Kakaraya 16
Sir Paulias Matane 19
The Speaker declared that Mr Bernard Narokobi be excluded from further ballot under s.9(3) of the Organic Law and proceeded to the fifth ballot. The results of the fifth ballot were as follows:
Sir Albert Kipalan 28
Sir Arnold Amet 20
Sir Pato Kakaraya 18
Sir Paulias Matane 25
The Speaker declared that Sir Pato Kakaraya be excluded from further ballot under s.9(3) of the Organic Law and proceeded to the sixth ballot. The results of the sixth ballot were as follows:
Sir Albert Kipalan 32
Sir Arnold Amet 27
Sir Paulias Matane 32
The Speaker declared that Sir Arnold Amet be excluded from further ballot under s.9(3) of the Organic Law and proceeded to the seventh, and final ballot which was conducted in accordance with s.8 of the Organic Law and the results were as follows:-
Sir Albert...
Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI
Get Started for FreeStart Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial of vLex and Vincent AI, Your Precision-Engineered Legal Assistant
-
Access comprehensive legal content with no limitations across vLex's unparalleled global legal database
-
Build stronger arguments with verified citations and CERT citator that tracks case history and precedential strength
-
Transform your legal research from hours to minutes with Vincent AI's intelligent search and analysis capabilities
-
Elevate your practice by focusing your expertise where it matters most while Vincent handles the heavy lifting
Start Your Free Trial
-
SC REF NO. 11 of 2008; Special reference pursuant to Constitution, s19. In The Matter of the Organic Law on the Integrity of Political Parties and Candidates Reference by the Provincial Executive Council of the Fly River Provincial Government of Western Province (Referrer) v The Registrar of Political Parties (first intervener) and the Integrity of Political Parties Commission (second intervener) and Dr Allan Marat, MP, Attorney General (third intervener) and The Hon. Jeffrey Nape, MP; Speaker of the National Parliament (fourth intervener) and the National Parliament (fifth intervener) and The Hon. Francis Awesa, MP (sixth intervener) and The Hon. Bart Philemon, MP (seventh intervener) (2010) SC1057
...on locus standi set out by this Court in the Somare case. Also see SC OS No. 2 of 2003; Re Election of Governor—General (No 1) (2003) SC721; Isidore Kaseng v Rabbie Namaliu (No. 1) [1995] PNGLR 481. 15. The referring authority must state the specific question that the Court is required to e......
-
SC REF NO.3 OF 2011; Reference pursuant to Constitution Section 19; Reference by the East Sepik Provincial Executive (-Referor-) and Hon. Dr Allan Marat, MP as The Minister for Justice and Attorney - General (-First Intervenor-) and Hon. Jeffery Nape MP, as Speaker of Parliament (-Second Intervenor-) and The Ombudsman Commission of Papua New Guinea (-Third Intervenor-) and Hon. Sam Abal MP (-Fourth Intervenor-) and Hon. Peter O'neill MP, as Prime Minister of Papua New Guinea (-Fifth Intervenor-) and Hon. Belden Namah MP, as the Deputy Prime Minister of Papua New Guinea (-Sixth Intervenor-) and National Alliance Inc. (-Seventh Intervenor-) and Grand Chief Sir Michael Somare MP (-Eighth Intervenor-) 2011 SC1154
...PNGLR 603 Re Election of Governor General; Reference by Morobe Provincial Executive (2010) SC1085 Re Election of Governor—General (No 1) (2003) SC721 Re Election of Governor—General (No 2) (2004) SC728 Re Election of Governor-General (No 3) (2004) SC752 Re Election of Governor-General (No 4......
-
Review Pursuant to the National Constitution; In the Matter of the Organic Law on the Nomination of Governor–General and In the Matter of an Application to Recall and Review a Supreme Court Decision in Relation to the Nomination of Governor General of Papua New Guinea; Application by Sir Pato Kakaraya; Sir Pato Kakaraya v Sir Albert Kipalan, Ila Geno, Chief Ombudsman, The National Parliament, Jeffrey Nape—Acting Speaker of National Parliament, Ano Pala, Clerk of National Parliament, The National Executive Council and The Rt Hon Sir Michael Somare, Prime Minister (2004) SC752
...Dennis Wallbank and Jeannette Minifie v The Independent State of Papua New Guinea [1994] PNGLR 78, Re Election of Governor–General (No 1) (2003) SC721, SCR No 3 of 1999 (No 2) (Unreported and Unnumbered Judgment of the Supreme Court dated 23 February 2001 or 23 July 2001), SCR 3 of 2000; Re......
-
Reference pursuant to Constitution, Section 18 (1); In the Matter of Forestry Act 199; Reference by Ken Norae Mondiai, John Mavramantz, Francis Demo, Pastor Lala Amsing, Johannes Awep and Jimmy Sina; In the Matter of the Forestry Act 1991 and the Forestry (Timber Permits Validation) Act 2007 (2010) SC1087
...Amendment Acts (2001) SC678; Re s18(1) of the Constitution and Bill Skate [2002] PNGLR 678; Re Election of Governor–General (No 1) (2003) SC721; Re Election of Governor–General (No 3) (2004) SC752; Re Petition of MT Somare [1981] PNGLR 265; Re s18(1) of the Constitution and Bill Skate [2002......
-
SC REF NO. 11 of 2008; Special reference pursuant to Constitution, s19. In The Matter of the Organic Law on the Integrity of Political Parties and Candidates Reference by the Provincial Executive Council of the Fly River Provincial Government of Western Province (Referrer) v The Registrar of Political Parties (first intervener) and the Integrity of Political Parties Commission (second intervener) and Dr Allan Marat, MP, Attorney General (third intervener) and The Hon. Jeffrey Nape, MP; Speaker of the National Parliament (fourth intervener) and the National Parliament (fifth intervener) and The Hon. Francis Awesa, MP (sixth intervener) and The Hon. Bart Philemon, MP (seventh intervener) (2010) SC1057
...on locus standi set out by this Court in the Somare case. Also see SC OS No. 2 of 2003; Re Election of Governor—General (No 1) (2003) SC721; Isidore Kaseng v Rabbie Namaliu (No. 1) [1995] PNGLR 481. 15. The referring authority must state the specific question that the Court is required to e......
-
SC REF NO.3 OF 2011; Reference pursuant to Constitution Section 19; Reference by the East Sepik Provincial Executive (-Referor-) and Hon. Dr Allan Marat, MP as The Minister for Justice and Attorney - General (-First Intervenor-) and Hon. Jeffery Nape MP, as Speaker of Parliament (-Second Intervenor-) and The Ombudsman Commission of Papua New Guinea (-Third Intervenor-) and Hon. Sam Abal MP (-Fourth Intervenor-) and Hon. Peter O'neill MP, as Prime Minister of Papua New Guinea (-Fifth Intervenor-) and Hon. Belden Namah MP, as the Deputy Prime Minister of Papua New Guinea (-Sixth Intervenor-) and National Alliance Inc. (-Seventh Intervenor-) and Grand Chief Sir Michael Somare MP (-Eighth Intervenor-) 2011 SC1154
...PNGLR 603 Re Election of Governor General; Reference by Morobe Provincial Executive (2010) SC1085 Re Election of Governor—General (No 1) (2003) SC721 Re Election of Governor—General (No 2) (2004) SC728 Re Election of Governor-General (No 3) (2004) SC752 Re Election of Governor-General (No 4......
-
Review Pursuant to the National Constitution; In the Matter of the Organic Law on the Nomination of Governor–General and In the Matter of an Application to Recall and Review a Supreme Court Decision in Relation to the Nomination of Governor General of Papua New Guinea; Application by Sir Pato Kakaraya; Sir Pato Kakaraya v Sir Albert Kipalan, Ila Geno, Chief Ombudsman, The National Parliament, Jeffrey Nape—Acting Speaker of National Parliament, Ano Pala, Clerk of National Parliament, The National Executive Council and The Rt Hon Sir Michael Somare, Prime Minister (2004) SC752
...Dennis Wallbank and Jeannette Minifie v The Independent State of Papua New Guinea [1994] PNGLR 78, Re Election of Governor–General (No 1) (2003) SC721, SCR No 3 of 1999 (No 2) (Unreported and Unnumbered Judgment of the Supreme Court dated 23 February 2001 or 23 July 2001), SCR 3 of 2000; Re......
-
Reference pursuant to Constitution, Section 18 (1); In the Matter of Forestry Act 199; Reference by Ken Norae Mondiai, John Mavramantz, Francis Demo, Pastor Lala Amsing, Johannes Awep and Jimmy Sina; In the Matter of the Forestry Act 1991 and the Forestry (Timber Permits Validation) Act 2007 (2010) SC1087
...Amendment Acts (2001) SC678; Re s18(1) of the Constitution and Bill Skate [2002] PNGLR 678; Re Election of Governor–General (No 1) (2003) SC721; Re Election of Governor–General (No 3) (2004) SC752; Re Petition of MT Somare [1981] PNGLR 265; Re s18(1) of the Constitution and Bill Skate [2002......