Tribunal Awards India First BIT Case Win, Dismissing Claims Of French Investor

An UNCITRAL arbitral tribunal has reportedly dismissed a US$36 million claim by a French investor, Louis Dreyfus Armateurs SAS ("LDA"), against India under the 1997 France-India bilateral investment treaty ("BIT"). The award is not public at this time, but press reports state that LDA has also been ordered to pay approximately US$7 million in respect of India's substantial legal expenses.

Background

The dispute concerns the Haldia Dock Complex, situated near Kolkata, under the authority of the Kolkata Port Trust. In 2010, LDA, the shipping business within the Louis Dreyfus Group conglomerate, became part of a joint venture as a minority indirect shareholder in a special purpose vehicle, Haldia Bulk Terminals Pvt Ltd (HBT), which was to carry out modernisation works at Haldia Docks. From 2012 a number of problems began to occur. A dispute arose between HBT and the Kolkata Port Trust over the removal of equipment and the project faced disruption due to trade union unrest following the dismissal of 275 workers, resulting in multiple pieces of litigation. Following the alleged armed kidnapping of company officers and members of an officer's family, the joint venture was abandoned.

In 2014, LDA filed a treaty claim under the BIT alleging that the Indian government had breached its treaty commitment to provide full protection and security, in particular as regards HBT's employees and their families, and was also in breach for its failure to follow court orders dealing with the removal of equipment. The claim gave rise to a request for an anti-arbitration injunction from the Calcutta High Court and a judgment on that application in September 2014. In December 2015, the tribunal ruled in India's favour, finding that LDA lacked...

To continue reading

Request your trial

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT