The State v James Yali (2005) N2988
Jurisdiction | Papua New Guinea |
Citation | (2005) N2988 |
Docket Number | CR No 368 of 2005 |
Court | National Court |
Year | 2005 |
Full Title: CR No 368 of 2005; The State v James Yali (2005) N2988
National Court: 13 December 2005
Judgment Delivered: Cannings J
1
Criminal law—indictable offence—Criminal Code, Division V.7, sexual offences and abduction—s350, abduction—trial on a charge of taking away a woman against her will, with intent to carnally know her—elements of offence—meaning of "against her will".
Criminal law—indictable offence—Criminal Code, Division V.7, sexual offences and abduction—s347, definition of rape—trial on a charge of rape under s347—elements of offence—meaning of "without … consent".
Criminal law—indictable offence—Criminal Code, Subdivision IV.2A, sexual offences against children—s229E, abuse of trust, authority or dependency—trial on a charge of engaging in an act of sexual penetration of a child between the ages of 16 and 18 years with whom the accused had an existing relationship of trust—elements of offence—dispute as to age of complainant—meaning of "relationship of trust"—Criminal Code, s6A.
Criminal law—indictable offence—Criminal Code, Division V.7, sexual offences and abduction—s349, sexual assault—trial on a charge of the accused touching with a part of his body the sexual parts of another person's body without consent—elements of offence.
Criminal Code—sexual offences and abduction offences—consent means free and voluntary agreement—Criminal Code, s347A, meaning of consent.
Criminal Code—sexual offences and abduction offences—Division V.7—abolition of warning against danger of convicting on the basis of uncorroborated testimony of complainant—Criminal Code, s352A, corroboration not required.
The State alleged that the accused, a middle–aged man, abducted and sexually penetrated the complainant, a youthful female, against her will and without her consent. In the alternative the State alleged that, if there were consent, the complainant was aged between the ages of 16 and 18 years and an offence was committed as there was an existing relationship of trust between her and the accused. Further in the alternative, the State alleged that the accused was guilty of sexual assault. Four charges were laid and the accused pleaded not guilty to all of them. Nineteen exhibits were admitted into evidence. The State called 18 witnesses. The defence case consisted of sworn evidence by the accused. He testified that he sexually penetrated the complainant with her consent.
Held:
(1) There was insufficient evidence to support the conclusion that the complainant had been taken away against her will. Therefore the accused was not guilty of abducting her.
(2) The prosecution discharged the onus of proving beyond reasonable doubt that the complainant did not consent to being sexually penetrated by the accused. There was no free and voluntary agreement. The elements of rape were established.
(3) The complainant was aged 17 at the time of the incident but there was no relationship of trust between her and the accused for the purposes of s229E of the Criminal Code.
(4) The complainant did not consent to being sexually touched by the accused. However, as this related to an alternative charge, no conviction was recorded.
(5) The accused was accordingly acquitted of abduction (count 1) and abuse of trust (count 3). He was convicted of rape (count 2). No conviction was recorded for sexual assault (count 4).
Black v Corkery (1988) 33 ACR 134, Holman v R [1970] WAR 2, John Jaminan v The State (No 2) [1983] PNGLR 318, R v Merembu Bongab [1971–1972] PNGLR 433, The State v Anton Kumak (1990) N835, The State v Bikhet Nguares Paulo [1994] PNGLR 335, The State v James Yali (2005) N2931, The State v James Yali (2005) N2932, The State v James Yali (2005) N2935, The State v Kewa Kai [1976] PNGLR 481, The State v Lucas Luma (2004) CR No 603 of 2004, unreported, The State v Michael Rave and Others [1993] PNGLR 85 referred to
Abbreviations
The following abbreviations appear in the judgment:
ACR—Australian Criminal Reports
ANZ—Australia and New Zealand
CBC—Christian Book Centre
CID—Criminal Investigations Division
Const—Constable
Dep—Deputy
Det—Detective
Dr—Doctor
Govt—Government
Hon—Honourable
Jr or Jnr—Junior
NCD—National Capital District
OIC—officer–in–charge
PMV—public motor vehicle
PNG—Papua New Guinea
PNGLR—Papua New Guinea Law Reports
Prov—Provincial
PSC—Police Station Commander
Sgt—Sergeant
Snr—senior
Tech—Technical
WAR—Western Australian Reports
TRIAL
This was the trial of an accused charged with abduction and rape and, in the alternative, abuse of trust and sexual assault.
VERDICT
_______________________________
CANNINGS J:
INTRODUCTION
This is a decision on the verdict for a man who pleaded not guilty to four sexually related offences.
BACKGROUND
Incident
The incident giving rise to the charges took place at Madang in October 2004. It is alleged that the complainant, a youthful female, was abducted and raped by the accused, a middle–aged man.
The alleged victim of the incident is referred to in this judgment as "the complainant", consistent with s1 of the Criminal Code, which says that that word means a person against whom an offence is alleged to have been committed.
Indictment
On 7 November 2005 the accused was brought before the National Court and faced the following indictment containing four charges:
Count No 1
JAMES YALI of SOR, RAI COAST, Madang Province is charged that he on the 13th day of October 2004 at Madang in Papua New Guinea with intent to carnally know OLIVIA DANIELS took her away against her will.
Count No 2
JAMES YALI of SOR, RAI COAST, Madang Province is charged that he on the 13th day of October 2004 at Madang in Papua New Guinea sexually penetrated OLIVIA DANIELS without her consent.
Count No 3
JAMES YALI of SOR, RAI COAST, Madang Province is charged that he on the 13th day of October 2004 at Madang in Papua New Guinea engaged in an act of sexual penetration of OLIVIA DANIELS a child between the ages of 16 and 18 years with whom he . . . has an existing relationship of trust.
Count No 4
JAMES YALI of SOR, RAI COAST, Madang Province is charged that he on the 13th day of October 2004 at Madang in Papua New Guinea without the consent of OLIVIA DANIELS touched with his hands the sexual parts of the said OLIVIA DANIELS.
The charges were laid under the following provisions of the Criminal Code:
• count 1—s350(1)(a), abduction;
• count 2—s 347, rape;
• count 3—s229E, abuse of trust, authority or dependency;
• count 4—s349, sexual assault.
The prosecutor, Mr Miviri, pointed out that the State would assert guilt under counts 1 and 2 in the first instance; and that counts 3 and 4 are alternatives to counts 1 and 2.
Arraignment
The accused pleaded not guilty to all four charges.
GLOSSARY
The following glossary lists the names of individuals and places referred to in the evidence.
Individuals
Adam Yawing—a police officer; State witness No 6
Alois Kingsley—a member of the Parliament; a friend of the accused
Alphonse Yohang—an uncle of the complainant; State witness No 2
Angela Yali—the accused's wife
Annette Kora—a cousin of the complainant; a lawyer
Arnold Amet Jr—a lawyer
Brian Daniels—a brother of the complainant
Daniel Kapen—a police officer; State witness No 11
Dr Lahui Geita—a doctor at Modilon Hospital; State witness No 14
Dr Monica Clement—a doctor at Modilon Hospital; State witness No 13
Elizabeth Daniels—the complainant's sister; the de facto wife of the accused; State witness No 5
Emile—a staff member of the accused
Emmanuel (Manu) Larry—a male friend of the complainant; State witness No 8
Garry Baki—Deputy Commissioner of Police
Grace—a woman said to be a friend of the accused
Helen Daniels—the complainant's mother; State witness No 3
Isaac Daniels—a brother of the complainant
James Yali—the accused
James Yali Jr—a son of the accused
Jenny Ariku—a police officer; State witness No 15
Jimmy Namora—Police Station Commander, Madang Police Station
Joe Parker—a staff member of the accused
Joe Pecks—a staff member of the accused
John Koito Bananga—a former employee of the Madang Provincial Government; State witness No 17
Johnson John—a male friend of the complainant; State witness No 7
June Kasiriri—a friend of the Daniels
Junior Diop—a male friend of the complainant and her brother, Oscar
Kevin Pamba—a journalist with The National
Kisikau Polaiap—Helen Daniels' brother
Markom Ururu—the accused's sister
Martina—an aunt of the complainant
Masbut—a staff member of the accused
Michael Kasi—the accused's First Secretary
Michael Ururu—the husband of the accused's sister
Mr Owen—a friend of the complainant
Olivia Daniels—the complainant; State witness No 1
Oscar Daniels—the...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
The State v James Yali (2006) N2989
...v George Taunde (2005) N2807, The State v Henry Nandiro (No 2) (2004) N2668, The State v James Yali (2005) N2931, The State v James Yali (2005) N2988, The State v John Ritsi Kutetoa (2005) N2814, The State v Julius Ombi (No 2) (2004) N2552, The State v Junior Apen Sibu (No 2) (2004) N2567, ......
-
Daniel Maiyau v the State (2017) SC1644
...The State v Daniel Kapen (2012) N4895 The State v Elias Mautu (2007) N5028 The State v Henry Levo (2015) N5902 The State v James Yali (2005) N2988 The State v Michael Nuli (2011) N4198 Welsh Samor v The State (2014) SC1398 Overseas Cases Browne v Dunn (1893) 6 R 67 (HL) APPEAL This was an a......
-
The State v Kikia Solowet (2007) N3154
...v The State [1988-89] PNGLR 562; Tommy Morikawa v The State (2000) SC656); The State v Saul Ogeram (2004) N2780; The State v James Yali (2005) N2988; The State v Jimmy Aiyo (2006) N4492; The State v Alex Hagali (2006) N4490 TRIAL This was the trial of an accused charged with persistent sexu......
-
CR. NO 1007 OF 2010; The State v Robin Andolu (No. 3) (2013) N5129
...Kapis Nanua (1997) N1659; The State v Ndrakum Pu–Uh (2005) N2949; The State v Lawrie Patrick [1995] PNGLR 195; The State v James Yali (2005) N2988; The State v Apolo Kesu [2006] Cr. 685 of 2004 (June 2006); The State v Francis Kavun (2013) N5114; John Aubuku v The State [1987] PNGLR 267 REA......
-
The State v James Yali (2006) N2989
...v George Taunde (2005) N2807, The State v Henry Nandiro (No 2) (2004) N2668, The State v James Yali (2005) N2931, The State v James Yali (2005) N2988, The State v John Ritsi Kutetoa (2005) N2814, The State v Julius Ombi (No 2) (2004) N2552, The State v Junior Apen Sibu (No 2) (2004) N2567, ......
-
Daniel Maiyau v the State (2017) SC1644
...The State v Daniel Kapen (2012) N4895 The State v Elias Mautu (2007) N5028 The State v Henry Levo (2015) N5902 The State v James Yali (2005) N2988 The State v Michael Nuli (2011) N4198 Welsh Samor v The State (2014) SC1398 Overseas Cases Browne v Dunn (1893) 6 R 67 (HL) APPEAL This was an a......
-
The State v Kikia Solowet (2007) N3154
...v The State [1988-89] PNGLR 562; Tommy Morikawa v The State (2000) SC656); The State v Saul Ogeram (2004) N2780; The State v James Yali (2005) N2988; The State v Jimmy Aiyo (2006) N4492; The State v Alex Hagali (2006) N4490 TRIAL This was the trial of an accused charged with persistent sexu......
-
CR. NO 1007 OF 2010; The State v Robin Andolu (No. 3) (2013) N5129
...Kapis Nanua (1997) N1659; The State v Ndrakum Pu–Uh (2005) N2949; The State v Lawrie Patrick [1995] PNGLR 195; The State v James Yali (2005) N2988; The State v Apolo Kesu [2006] Cr. 685 of 2004 (June 2006); The State v Francis Kavun (2013) N5114; John Aubuku v The State [1987] PNGLR 267 REA......