and in re: A Disputed Return in a General Election for the West New Britain Provincial Electorate in the 1997 General Elections; Greg Mongi v Bernard Vogae and The Electoral Commission (1997) N1635
Jurisdiction | Papua New Guinea |
Judgment Date | 24 October 1997 |
Docket Number | In re The Organic Law on National and Local-level Government Elections |
Year | 1997 |
Citation | (1997) N1635 |
Court | National Court |
Judgement Number | N1635 |
Full Title: In re The Organic Law on National and Local-level Government Elections; and in re: A Disputed Return in a General Election for the West New Britain Provincial Electorate in the 1997 General Elections; Greg Mongi v Bernard Vogae and The Electoral Commission (1997) N1635
National Court: Injia J
Judgment Delivered: 24 October 1997
N1635
PAPUA NEW GUINEA
[NATIONAL COURT OF JUSTICE]
EP NO. 49 OF 1997
IN RE: THE ORGANIC LAW ON NATIONAL AND LOCAL-LEVEL GOVERNMENT ELECTIONS
AND IN RE: A DISPUTED RETURN IN A GENERAL ELECTION FOR THE WEST NEW BRITAIN PROVINCIAL ELECTORATE IN THE 1997 GENERAL ELECTIONS
BETWEEN
GREG MONGI — PETITIONER
AND
BERNARD VOGAE — FIRST RESPONDENT
AND
THE ELECTORAL COMMISSION — SECOND RESPONDENT
Waigani
Injia J
21 October 1997
24 October 1997
Counsel
J Sirigoi for the Petitioner
G Manda for the First Respondent
J Nonggorr for the Second Respondent
24 October 1997
INJIA J: The respondents by separate motions apply to dismiss the election petition filed pursuant to s. 206 of the Organic Law on National and Local-level Government Elections No. 3 of 1997 (hereinafter abbreviated OLNE) on 8 August 1997. The applications are based on two grounds namely: (1) that the Petition fails to comply with OLNE s. 208 (a) in that the petition does not set out sufficient facts to support the grounds of bribery and errors or omissions; (2) that the petition fails to comply with s. 208 (b) in that the petition does not set out the correct relief the petitioner is entitled to seek under OLNE, s. 215 (1). I will deal with the latter ground first. If I decide to dismiss the petition on this ground alone, it may become unnecessary to decide the first ground.
The provisions of the OLNE relevant for the purpose of this exercise are s. 208 (a) & (b) and s. 210 but for completeness sake I set out Ss. 208, 209 & 210 in full:
"208. Requisites of Petition
A petition shall:
(a) set out the facts relied on to invalidate the election or return; and
(b) specify the relief to which the petitioner claims to be entitled; and
(c) be signed by a candidate at the election in dispute or by a person who was qualified to vote at the election; and
(d) be attested by two witnesses whose occupations and addresses are stated; and
(e) be filed in the Registry of the National Court at Port Moresby or at the court house in any Provincial headquarters within 40 days after the declaration of the result of the election in accordance with Section 175 (1) (a).
209. Deposit as Security for Costs
At the time of filing the petition the petitioner shall deposit with the Registrar of the National Court the sum of K2,500.00 as security for costs.
210. No Proceedings unless Requisites Complied with
Proceedings shall not be heard on a petition unless the requirements of Sections 208 and 209 are complied with."
The principles relating to the construction and application of the above provisions are well settled in this jurisdiction. An election petition must strictly comply with the mandatory requirements of s. 208 and no petition can proceed to a substantive (evidentiary) hearing unless each and every requirement in s. 208 is strictly complied with. Failure to comply with s. 208 can result in an election petition being struckout or dismissed at a preliminary stage of the proceedings: see Biri v Ninkama [1982] PNGLR 342; Holloway v Ivarato [1988] PNGLR 99, SC Rev. No. 45 of 1994 re: William Elaip Wii, Unreported Supreme Court judgment dated 26 July 1994. The decision in Re William Wii is an unnumbered decision which means the decision was not published or circulated outside of the judiciary.
The principles in relation to s. 208 (b) specifically were settled by the Supreme Court in Re William Wii. In that case, the Petitioner, Mr Michael Mel, filed a petition disputing the election of Mr Wii as the member for the Aglimp South Whagi open electorate in the Western Highlands Province in the 1992 general elections. The petition contained allegations of bribery committed by Mr Wii. These allegations fell under OLNE, s. 215 (1) which provided that "If the National Court finds that a candidate has committed or attempted to commit bribery or undue influence, his election, if he is a successful candidate shall be declared void". The relief set out in the petition were inter alia, an order "that the First Respondent was not duly elected" and "that the election for the Aglimp — South Whagi Open electorate is null and void". After conducting a substantive evidentiary hearing, the National Court found the allegations of bribery made...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
David Kuna v Vincent Eralia, Presiding Magistrate and The Independent State Of Papua New Guinea and Rali Kawane (2004) N2771
...SC590, Peter Simbi v John Masueng [1999] PNGLR 171, Edward Ramu Diro v Ombudsman Commission (1991) N1385, Greg Mongi v Bernard Vogae (1997) N1635, Iambakey Okuk v John Nilkare [1983] PNGLR 28, Jim Kas v The Independent State of Papua New Guinea (2000) N2010, Joel Pepa Paua v Robert Timo Nga......
-
In the matter of Organic Law on National and Local-Level Government Elections and in the matter of Elections and Returns for Hagen Open Electorate, Western Highlands Province; James Yoka Ekip and Simon Sanagke v Gordon Wimb, Returning Officer and Electoral Commissioner of Papua New Guinea and William Duma (2012) N4899
...Karo [1992] PNGLR 463; Vagi Mae v Jack Genia and Electoral Commissioner of PNG; Re Abau Open Seat (1992) N1105; Greg Mongi v Bernard Vogae (1997) N1635; Torato v Balakau [1988–89] PNGLR 83; Aiwa Olmi v Nick Kopia Kuman (2002) N2310; Joel Pepa Paua v Robert Timo Ngale [1992] PNGLR 563; Ben M......
-
In the matter of the Organic Law on National and Local-Level Government Elections and in the matter of Disputed Returns for the Laigap-Porgera Open Electorate; Philip Kikala v Electoral Commission of Papua New Guinea and Nixon Koeka Mangape (2013) N4960
...Gaima [1997] PNGLR 645; Dick Mune v Anderson Agiru (1998) SC590; Ludger Mond v Jeffery Nape (2003) N2318; Greg Mongi v Bernard Vogae (1997) N1635; Alfred Manase v Don Pomb Polye (2008) N3534; Francis Koimanrea v Alois Sumunda [2003] PNGLR 264 Text & References Oxford Advanced Learner’s Dict......
-
In The Matter of The Organic Law on National and Local–level Government Elections; And In The Matter of A Disputed Return for The Goroka Open Electorate; Mathias Ijape v Bire Kimisopa and The Electoral Commission of Papua New Guinea (2003) N2344
...PNGLR 83, Joel Pepa Paua v Robert Timo Ngale [1992] PNGLR 563, Iambakey Okuk v John Nilkare [1983] PNGLR 28, Greg Mongi v Bernard Vogae (1997) N1635, Louis Ambane v Thomas Tumun Sumuno (1998) SC559, Albert Karo v Lady Carol Kidu [1997] PNGLR 28, Special Reference pursuant to Constitution Se......
-
David Kuna v Vincent Eralia, Presiding Magistrate and The Independent State Of Papua New Guinea and Rali Kawane (2004) N2771
...SC590, Peter Simbi v John Masueng [1999] PNGLR 171, Edward Ramu Diro v Ombudsman Commission (1991) N1385, Greg Mongi v Bernard Vogae (1997) N1635, Iambakey Okuk v John Nilkare [1983] PNGLR 28, Jim Kas v The Independent State of Papua New Guinea (2000) N2010, Joel Pepa Paua v Robert Timo Nga......
-
In the matter of Organic Law on National and Local-Level Government Elections and in the matter of Elections and Returns for Hagen Open Electorate, Western Highlands Province; James Yoka Ekip and Simon Sanagke v Gordon Wimb, Returning Officer and Electoral Commissioner of Papua New Guinea and William Duma (2012) N4899
...Karo [1992] PNGLR 463; Vagi Mae v Jack Genia and Electoral Commissioner of PNG; Re Abau Open Seat (1992) N1105; Greg Mongi v Bernard Vogae (1997) N1635; Torato v Balakau [1988–89] PNGLR 83; Aiwa Olmi v Nick Kopia Kuman (2002) N2310; Joel Pepa Paua v Robert Timo Ngale [1992] PNGLR 563; Ben M......
-
In the matter of the Organic Law on National and Local-Level Government Elections and in the matter of Disputed Returns for the Laigap-Porgera Open Electorate; Philip Kikala v Electoral Commission of Papua New Guinea and Nixon Koeka Mangape (2013) N4960
...Gaima [1997] PNGLR 645; Dick Mune v Anderson Agiru (1998) SC590; Ludger Mond v Jeffery Nape (2003) N2318; Greg Mongi v Bernard Vogae (1997) N1635; Alfred Manase v Don Pomb Polye (2008) N3534; Francis Koimanrea v Alois Sumunda [2003] PNGLR 264 Text & References Oxford Advanced Learner’s Dict......
-
In The Matter of The Organic Law on National and Local–level Government Elections; And In The Matter of A Disputed Return for The Goroka Open Electorate; Mathias Ijape v Bire Kimisopa and The Electoral Commission of Papua New Guinea (2003) N2344
...PNGLR 83, Joel Pepa Paua v Robert Timo Ngale [1992] PNGLR 563, Iambakey Okuk v John Nilkare [1983] PNGLR 28, Greg Mongi v Bernard Vogae (1997) N1635, Louis Ambane v Thomas Tumun Sumuno (1998) SC559, Albert Karo v Lady Carol Kidu [1997] PNGLR 28, Special Reference pursuant to Constitution Se......