Soka Toligai as President of Sentral Niu Ailan Local Level Government v Sir Julius Chan, the Governor of New Ireland Province and Amani Monovi, the Administrator, New Ireland Province (2012) N4842
Jurisdiction | Papua New Guinea |
Judgment Date | 18 July 2012 |
Docket Number | OS 173 of 2012 |
Year | 2012 |
Citation | (2012) N4842 |
Court | National Court |
Judgement Number | N4842 |
Full Title: OS 173 of 2012; Soka Toligai as President of Sentral Niu Ailan Local Level Government v Sir Julius Chan, the Governor of New Ireland Province and Amani Monovi, the Administrator, New Ireland Province (2012) N4842
National Court: Hartshorn J
Judgment Delivered: 18 July 2012
N4842
PAPUA NEW GUINEA
[IN THE NATIONAL COURT OF JUSTICE]
OS 173 OF 2012
BETWEEN:
SOKA TOLIGAI as President of Sentral
Niu Ailan Local Level Government
Plaintiff
AND:
SIR JULIUS CHAN, the Governor
of New Ireland Province
First Defendant
AND:
AMANI MONOVI, the Administrator,
New Ireland Province
Second Defendant
Kokopo: Hartshorn J.
2012: 17th, 18th July
Application to dismiss proceeding – Order 12 Rule 40 National Court Rules - privity of contract – proceeding bound to fail - frivolous
Facts:
The defendants have applied to dismiss this proceeding. They submit that the plaintiff does not have the necessary standing or locus standi to seek the relief that he does. The plaintiff submits that he does have the necessary standing as he is the President of a Local Level Government that is referred to in the Agreement pursuant to which relief is sought.
Held:
The plaintiff is not a party to the Lihir Agreement and so does not have the necessary standing to seek the relief that he does and no cause of action is disclosed against the defendants. The proceeding is bound to fail and consequently is frivolous.
Cases cited:
Ronny Wabia v. BP Exploration Operating Co Ltd [1998] PNGLR 8
PNGBC v. Barra Amevo & Ors (1998) N1726
Christian Life Centre v. Associated Mission Churches of PNG & Ors (2002) N2261
The Papua Club Inc v. Nusaum Holdings Ltd (No. 2) (2004) N2603
Kiee Toap v. The State (2004) N2731, N2766
Lerro v. Stagg (2006) N 3050
Ben Maoko v. Kevin Ling (2008) N3293
Counsel:
Mr. R. Asa, for the Plaintiff
Mr. J. Kusip, for the Defendants
18th July, 2012
1. HARTSHORN J: The defendants have applied to dismiss this proceeding. They submit that the plaintiff does not have the necessary standing or locus standi to seek the relief that he does. The plaintiff submits that he does have the necessary standing as he is the President of a Local Level Government that is referred to in the Agreement pursuant to which relief is sought.
2. In this proceeding the plaintiff seeks declaratory and consequential relief to the effect that certain royalty payments referred to in the Revised Memorandum of Agreement relating to the Lihir Gold Mining Project between the State, New Ireland Provincial Government, The Nimar Rural Local Level Government and The Lihir Mining Area Landowners Association Inc. dated 2 May 2007 (Lihir Agreement), belong to the Sentral Niu Ailan Local Level Government (SNA LLG).
3. The defendants apply to dismiss this proceeding pursuant to Order 12 Rule 40 National Court Rules as it is frivolous or vexatious or an abuse of the process of this court.
4. It is clear upon a perusal of the Lihir Agreement that the plaintiff is not a party to it. Further, contrary to the submissions of the plaintiff, in clauses 6 (c) (i) and 23 (i) of the Lihir Agreement upon which the plaintiff relies, the references are to “Namatanai District” and not the SNA LLG.
5. Pursuant to the doctrine of privity of contract, “…. no person can sue or be sued on a contract unless he or she is a party to it: Dunlop Pneumatic Tyre Co Ltd v. Selfridge & Co Ltd [1915] AC 847. The doctrine of privity means a contract cannot as a general rule confer rights or impose obligations arising under it on any person except the parties to it.” : Christian Life Centre v. Associated Mission Churches of PNG & Ors (2002) N2261, per Lenalia J.
6. Other decisions in this jurisdiction have considered and ruled pursuant to the doctrine of privity of contract: PNGBC v. Barra Amevo & Ors (1998) N1726, The Papua Club Inc v. Nusaum Holdings Ltd (No. 2) (2004) N2603 and Ben Maoko v. Kevin Ling (2008) N3293.
7. In Ben Maoko (supra), Cannings J referred to exceptions to the doctrine of privity of contract. In the case before him no exceptions were pleaded. In this case as well, no exceptions are pleaded, or referred to in submissions.
8. Counsel for the plaintiff referred to there being an implied trust between the New Ireland Provincial Government and the SNA LLG. Even if a trust was implied, and I do not consider this, as referred to, there is no reference to the SNA LLG in the Lihir Agreement.
9. A further factor that is able to be considered in determining whether this proceeding is frivolous or vexatious is whether the plaintiff has a cause of action against the named defendants. Here, as the New Ireland Provincial Government is not named as a party to this proceeding; only the Governor and Administrator of the Province are so named, and they are not parties to the Lihir...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Idutu Koiari Development Company Ltd v Tribal Investment Ltd
...BP Exploration Operating Co Ltd [1998] PNGLR 8 Siu v. Wasime Land Group Incorporated (2011) SC1107 Soka Toligai v. Sir Julius Chan and Ors (2012) N4842 Takori v.Yagari & Ors (2008) SC905 Mt Hagen Urban Local Level Government v. Sek No. 15 (2009) SC1007 National Fisheries Authority v. New Br......
-
R & Sons Construction Ltd v Dr Ken Ngangan, Secretary for Finance and the Independent State of Papua New Guinea (2017) N8365
...Mt Hagen Urban Local Level Government v. Sek No. 15 (2009) SC1007 Siu v. Wasime Land Group Incorporated (2011) SC1107 Toligai v. Chan (2012) N4842. Overseas Cases Brimson v. Rocla Concrete Pipes Ltd [1982] 2 NSWLR 937 Burton v. Shire of Bairnsdale (1908) 7 CLR 76 Dey v. Victorian Railways C......
-
Lane Kult Pill Onga v Theresia Bob and Others
...(2014) SC1420 Philip v Tiliyago (2019) SC1783 Re Estate of Joseph Kubak Demas (2017) N7044 Singut v Kinamun (2003) N2499 Toligai v Chan (2012) N4842 Taila v Silas (2018) N7334 Wari v Dekenai Construction Ltd (2017) N7649 Legislation: Land Registration Act 1981: ss. 2(1), 2(2), 171. National......
-
Dekenai Constructions Limited v Tati Keke Resources Limited And Andrew Feari & Pisai Feareka (2019) SC1800
...Areng v. Gregory Babia (2005) N2895 The Papuan Club Inc. v Nusaum Holdings Ltd (No. 2)(2004) N2603 Soka Toligai v. Sir Julius Chan and Ors (2012) N4842 Dumal Dibiaso Incorporated Land Group v. Kola Kuma (2005) SC805 Vunaibu Incorporated Land Group Inc. v. Michael Wilson (2017) N6806 Nichola......
-
Idutu Koiari Development Company Ltd v Tribal Investment Ltd
...BP Exploration Operating Co Ltd [1998] PNGLR 8 Siu v. Wasime Land Group Incorporated (2011) SC1107 Soka Toligai v. Sir Julius Chan and Ors (2012) N4842 Takori v.Yagari & Ors (2008) SC905 Mt Hagen Urban Local Level Government v. Sek No. 15 (2009) SC1007 National Fisheries Authority v. New Br......
-
R & Sons Construction Ltd v Dr Ken Ngangan, Secretary for Finance and the Independent State of Papua New Guinea (2017) N8365
...Mt Hagen Urban Local Level Government v. Sek No. 15 (2009) SC1007 Siu v. Wasime Land Group Incorporated (2011) SC1107 Toligai v. Chan (2012) N4842. Overseas Cases Brimson v. Rocla Concrete Pipes Ltd [1982] 2 NSWLR 937 Burton v. Shire of Bairnsdale (1908) 7 CLR 76 Dey v. Victorian Railways C......
-
Lane Kult Pill Onga v Theresia Bob and Others
...(2014) SC1420 Philip v Tiliyago (2019) SC1783 Re Estate of Joseph Kubak Demas (2017) N7044 Singut v Kinamun (2003) N2499 Toligai v Chan (2012) N4842 Taila v Silas (2018) N7334 Wari v Dekenai Construction Ltd (2017) N7649 Legislation: Land Registration Act 1981: ss. 2(1), 2(2), 171. National......
-
Dekenai Constructions Limited v Tati Keke Resources Limited And Andrew Feari & Pisai Feareka (2019) SC1800
...Areng v. Gregory Babia (2005) N2895 The Papuan Club Inc. v Nusaum Holdings Ltd (No. 2)(2004) N2603 Soka Toligai v. Sir Julius Chan and Ors (2012) N4842 Dumal Dibiaso Incorporated Land Group v. Kola Kuma (2005) SC805 Vunaibu Incorporated Land Group Inc. v. Michael Wilson (2017) N6806 Nichola......