Yakananda Business Group Inc v Minister for Lands and Physical Planning and The Independent State of Papua New Guinea (2001) N2159
Jurisdiction | Papua New Guinea |
Judgment Date | 07 December 2001 |
Citation | (2001) N2159 |
Year | 2001 |
Court | National Court |
Judgement Number | N2159 |
Full Title: Yakananda Business Group Inc v Minister for Lands and Physical Planning and The Independent State of Papua New Guinea (2001) N2159
National Court: Sevua J
Judgment Delivered: 7 December 2001
N2159
PAPUA NEW GUINEA
[In the National Court of Justice]
OS 170 of 1996 (H)
BETWEEN
YAKANANDA BUSINESS GROUP INC.
Plaintiff
AND
MINISTER FOR LANDS & PHYSICAL PLANNING
First Defendant
AND
THE INDEPENDENT STATE OF PAPUA NEW GUINEA
Second Defendant
Mount Hagen & Waigani: Sevua, J
2001: 17th July & 7th December
Administrative Law — Judicial Review — Review of administrative action — Decision of Minister for Lands forfeiting residential lease — Notice to show cause — Not issued prior to forfeiture — Non-compliance with Land Act, s.46(2).
Judicial Review — Forfeiture of lease — Notice of show cause — Whether lessee entitled to receipt of notice prior to forfeiture — Whether breach of s.46(2) constitutes error on face of record — Whether judicial review available.
Held: (1) The issuing of notice to show cause by the Minister is a mandatory
requirement of law therefore the lessee is entitled to be served with notice and is entitled to explain why the lease ought not to be forfeited.
(2) There is error on the face of the record warranting the exercise of the Court's discretion in favour of the plaintiff.
(3) Judicial Review is available where the Minister for Lands has ordered forfeiture of lease contrary to the mandatory requirements of s.46(2) of the Land Act, Ch 185.
Cases cited:
Kekedo v. Burns Philp (PNG) Ltd & Ors [1988-89] PNGLR 122
P. Kunai for Plaintiff
J. Kais for Defendants
7th December, 2001
SEVUA, J: This is the substantive judicial review application, leave having been granted on 26th June 1996. The review is in respect of the decision of the first defendant made on 26th July 1995 whereby he revoked the grant of a lease to the plaintiff over land described as Portion 259, Millinch Wapenamanda, Fourmil Wabag, Enga Province, and forfeited the land to the State.
The facts of this case are quite brief. Pursuant to s.54 of the Land Act, Chapter 185, the Minister for Lands granted a residential lease to the plaintiff for a term of 99 years from the 14th April 1988 to the 13th April 2087. The annual land rent for the first ten (10) years was K350.00 payable in advance on the first day of January each year. The improvement covenant in the lease was that the lessee must erect buildings for residence purposes to a minimum value of K200,000.00.
On 30th July 1994, Joseph Aoae, a delegate of the Minister for Lands & Physical Planning, issued a notice to show cause to the plaintiff pursuant to s.46 (1)(a) of the Land Act, Ch 185. The plaintiff was requested to show cause why the lease should not be forfeited on the grounds that, it had failed to pay the rent for a period of more than six months, and secondly, the plaintiff had refused or neglected to comply with the improvement covenant in the lease.
On 26th July 1995, then Minister for Lands, Sir Albert Kipalan, issued a forfeiture notice on the grounds that firstly, the improvement conditions imposed by the Act have not been fulfilled in respect of the land; and secondly, the rent remained due and unpaid for a period of more than six months.
The plaintiff subsequently instituted these proceedings on 12th April 1996, by way of originating summons, seeking leave for a judicial review; an order for a prerogative writ of certiorari to remove into this Court and quash the decision of the Minister for Lands and Physical Planning; and a declaration that the plaintiff is still the lessee of the land, the subject of these proceedings.
At the outset, when this application was made on 17th July 2001, counsel for the plaintiff, Mr Kunai, informed the Court that this matter had been outstanding for some years now. It should have been dealt with a long time ago, but the trial date continued to be vacated. I alluded to this at this stage because, at the end of the plaintiff's evidence, counsel requested an adjournment for three days to enable the plaintiff to produce to the Court, evidence of payment of rent. The Court refused that request after the defendants objected to it. It has been five (5) years and twenty (20) days to be exact, since leave was granted, and the plaintiff should have prepared for hearing today. It should have brought its rental receipts available for production.
Furthermore, during a mini call-over on Monday, 9th July 2001, the trial date previously scheduled for 24th July 2001, was vacated and brought forward to 17th July, because a number of trials for this month's circuit had to be vacated and the list rescheduled. In my view, the plaintiff and its lawyers have had more than sufficient time to prepare their case for trial. The failure by the plaintiff to provide vital evidence therefore cannot be attributed to the Court's refusal to grant an adjournment. It is the plaintiff's own making, and I find that the plaintiff had no valid reason for failing to produce the relevant evidence relating to payment of rent. One would have been forgiven if the question of non-payment of rent was not an issue in this matter, however it was, and is, an issue. In my view...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Evangelical Lutheran Church of PNG v Gunar Gee
...v Sali Tagau (2016) N6159 West New Britain Provincial Government v Kimas (2009) N3834 Yakananda Business Group Inc v Minister for Lands (2001) N2159 STATEMENT OF CLAIM This was an application for declarations and orders regarding a State Lease. Counsel S Gor & J Kihanges, for the Plaintiff ......
-
Open Bay Timber Limited and Papua New Guinea Forest Authority v Hon Lucas Dekena, Minister for Lands & Physical Planning and Henry Wasa, Registrar of Titles and The Independent State of Papua New Guinea and Secretary, Department of Lands & Physical Planning and Papua New Guinea Land Board and Tzen Plantations Limited (2013) N5109
...N4777; WNB Provincial Government v Pepi S Kimas (2009) N3834; Yakananda Business Group Inc v Minister for Lands and Physical Planning (2001) N2159 Overseas Cases Associated Provincial Picture Houses Ltd v Wednesbury Corporation [1948] 1 KB 223 1. CANNINGS J: This is a ruling on an applicati......
-
West New Britain Provincial Government v Pepi S Kimas, Secretary, Department of Lands and Physical Planning and Francis Tanga, Chairman, Land Board, & Members of The Land Board and The Independent State of Papua New Guinea and Qunqing Trading Ltd (2009) N3834
...The Papua Club Inc v Nusaum Holdings Ltd (No 2) (2004) N2603; Yakananda Business Group Inc v Minister for Lands and Physical Planning (2001) N2159 30 December, 2009 1. CANNINGS J: There is a vacant block of land in the centre of Kimbe, the capital of West New Britain Province, which has bec......
-
Doriga Mahuru, Maiva Mahuru, Mahuru Doriga, Max Doriga & Kuruku Nao v Hon Lucas Dekena, Minister For Lands & Physical Planning and John Ofoi, Acting Secretary, Department of Lands & Physical Planning and Henry Wasa, Registrar of Titles and The Independent State of Papua New Guinea and Ava Mika, Kila Gabutu & Michael John Madi (2013) N5305
...Exxon Mobil Ltd (2012) N4844 West New Britain Provincial Government v Kimas (2009) N3834 Yakananda Business Group Inc v Minister for Lands (2001) N2159 JUDICIAL REVIEW This was a review of decisions resulting in the Minister for Lands and Physical Planning granting a Special Agricultural an......
-
Evangelical Lutheran Church of PNG v Gunar Gee
...v Sali Tagau (2016) N6159 West New Britain Provincial Government v Kimas (2009) N3834 Yakananda Business Group Inc v Minister for Lands (2001) N2159 STATEMENT OF CLAIM This was an application for declarations and orders regarding a State Lease. Counsel S Gor & J Kihanges, for the Plaintiff ......
-
Open Bay Timber Limited and Papua New Guinea Forest Authority v Hon Lucas Dekena, Minister for Lands & Physical Planning and Henry Wasa, Registrar of Titles and The Independent State of Papua New Guinea and Secretary, Department of Lands & Physical Planning and Papua New Guinea Land Board and Tzen Plantations Limited (2013) N5109
...N4777; WNB Provincial Government v Pepi S Kimas (2009) N3834; Yakananda Business Group Inc v Minister for Lands and Physical Planning (2001) N2159 Overseas Cases Associated Provincial Picture Houses Ltd v Wednesbury Corporation [1948] 1 KB 223 1. CANNINGS J: This is a ruling on an applicati......
-
West New Britain Provincial Government v Pepi S Kimas, Secretary, Department of Lands and Physical Planning and Francis Tanga, Chairman, Land Board, & Members of The Land Board and The Independent State of Papua New Guinea and Qunqing Trading Ltd (2009) N3834
...The Papua Club Inc v Nusaum Holdings Ltd (No 2) (2004) N2603; Yakananda Business Group Inc v Minister for Lands and Physical Planning (2001) N2159 30 December, 2009 1. CANNINGS J: There is a vacant block of land in the centre of Kimbe, the capital of West New Britain Province, which has bec......
-
Doriga Mahuru, Maiva Mahuru, Mahuru Doriga, Max Doriga & Kuruku Nao v Hon Lucas Dekena, Minister For Lands & Physical Planning and John Ofoi, Acting Secretary, Department of Lands & Physical Planning and Henry Wasa, Registrar of Titles and The Independent State of Papua New Guinea and Ava Mika, Kila Gabutu & Michael John Madi (2013) N5305
...Exxon Mobil Ltd (2012) N4844 West New Britain Provincial Government v Kimas (2009) N3834 Yakananda Business Group Inc v Minister for Lands (2001) N2159 JUDICIAL REVIEW This was a review of decisions resulting in the Minister for Lands and Physical Planning granting a Special Agricultural an......