Court Applies The 'At Issue' Doctrine

The "at issue" doctrine represents the most frightening type of implied waiver. Litigants can trigger such a waiver without disclosing, referring to, or relying on privileged communications. Instead, an "at issue" waiver can occur if litigants assert some position that necessarily places "at issue" such privileged communications.

In Gefre v. Davis Wright Tremaine, LLP, 306 P.3d 1264 (Alaska 2013), shareholders filed a derivative action against a company's director and former law firm. The shareholders alleged that defendants engaged in fraudulent conduct of which the shareholders were unaware - although they were represented at the time by their own lawyer. The court found an "at issue" waiver - explaining that the shareholders "cannot be permitted to thrust their lack of knowledge into the litigation while simultaneously retaining the...