Court Of Appeal Provides Guidance On Proportionality In The Assessment Of General Damages

• Published date: 06 December 2022
• Law Firm: RDJ LLP
• Author: Mr Padraic Brennan and Thomas McInerney

Background

The recent judgment of the Court of Appeal delivered on the 8^th of September 2022 in Kevin Meehan v Shawcove Ltd and Ors¹ provides helpful guidance on how the courts must approach an assessment of general damages in cases involving multiple injuries, as well as on how the courts must consider the proportionality of an assessment of general damages in light of the maximum award permitted.

This was an appeal against the manner in which the High Court had assessed the level of general damages and loss of opportunity in its judgment last year. Hanna J awarded the Plaintiff '375,000, comprising '125,000 for pain and suffering to date, '175,000 for pain and suffering into the future and '75,000 for loss of opportunity.

The Court of Appeal Decision

In his judgment, Noonan J, with Faherty and Binchy JJ agreeing, made it quite clear that he had the utmost respect for Mr Meehan's drive and perseverance in spearheading his impressive recovery from what were very serious injuries and in returning remarkably soon to his successful career. He had suffered fractures to his back and legs, various soft tissue and dental injuries, as well as PTSD and depression after a lift he was in collapsed. He had ongoing knee pain and would eventually require surgery - including...