English Court Of Appeal Refuses Micula Appeal Against Stay Of ICSID Award But Orders Romania To Provide £150m Security

In Micula & Ors v Romania [2018] EWCA Civ 1801 the English Court of Appeal (the "Court") dismissed an appeal against the High Court's stay of enforcement of a 2013 ICSID award in favour of Swedish investors Ioan and Viorel Micula (the "Appellants" or "claimants") against Romania (the "Award"), but allowed an appeal against the High Court's refusal to order Romania to provide security.

The Court's judgment is interesting because although it reaches the same conclusion as the High Court in respect of staying enforcement of the Award, it does so for different reasons. In particular, the Court found (by majority) that:

The High Court was correct to find that an ICSID award is res judicata under English law from the time of the award. Although the English Arbitration (International Investment Disputes) Act 1966 (the "1966 Act"), which implements the ICSID Convention into English law, requires that ICSID awards be treated in the same way as judgments of the High Court, this does not mean that EU law applies in the same way as it would apply to domestic judgments simply because the UK is a member state at the date of registration of the award. The principle of res judicata cannot be used to circumvent or significantly obstruct state aid rules (per the CJEU case of Klausner). Only operative terms (and not, for example, recitals) of EU Commission decisions are legally binding. The Court's decision is the latest in the long-running Micula saga, which began as a dispute arising out of Romania's abolition of certain tax incentives in 2005 in order to comply with EU rules on state aid. Please see here for our blog post on the ICSID award.

The Award has been the target of decisions of the European Commission. In its final decision of 30 March 2015 (the "Final Decision"), the Commission found that payment of the Award by Romania would constitute new state aid incompatible with EU law, and was therefore prohibited. Please see here for our blog post...