Jeffrey Afozah v The Police Commissioner, The Department of Police and The Independent State of Papua New Guinea (2008) N3300
Jurisdiction | Papua New Guinea |
Court | National Court |
Date | 07 April 2008 |
Citation | (2008) N3300 |
Docket Number | OS NO 330 OF 2002 |
Year | 2008 |
Full Title: OS NO 330 OF 2002; Jeffrey Afozah v The Police Commissioner, The Department of Police and The Independent State of Papua New Guinea (2008) N3300
National Court: Cannings J
Judgment Delivered: 7 April 2008
JUDICIAL REVIEW—disciplinary proceedings—review of decision of Commissioner of Police to find police officer guilty of disciplinary offence—natural justice—taking into account irrelevant considerations—reasons for decision not corresponding with charge laid.
The Commissioner of Police charged the plaintiff, a police officer, with a serious disciplinary offence: being absent from duty without authorised leave for a period of three months and ten days. He found him guilty and dismissed him from the Police Force. The plaintiff sought judicial review on the grounds that (1) as to the guilty finding, the Commissioner (a) denied him natural justice by not considering his written reply to the charge and (b) took into account irrelevant considerations; and (2) as to the decision to dismiss him, the Commissioner (a) denied him natural justice by not giving him the opportunity to be heard on the question of penalty and (b) took irrelevant considerations into account.
Held:
(1) As to the decision to find the plaintiff guilty:
(a) there was no denial of natural justice as, although the Commissioner did not consider the plaintiff’s reply to the charge, the plaintiff could not prove that he served it on the Commissioner;
(b) the Commissioner erred in law by taking into account an irrelevant consideration, viz that the plaintiff was absent from duty for six months, when the charge alleged that he was absent for three months and ten days.
(2) As to the decision to find the plaintiff guilty:
(a) there was no denial of natural justice as the Commissioner is not obliged, having found an officer guilty of a disciplinary offence, to grant a separate hearing on penalty;
(b) the Commissioner erred in law by taking into account irrelevant considerations, viz recommendations for dismissal from two senior officers under whose command the plaintiff had never served, the six month absence finding and a finding that the plaintiff was a “repeat offender” when there was no evidence of that.
(3) The error of law made in the decision to find the plaintiff guilty was a significant one, warranting the quashing of that decision.
(4) The error of law made in the decision to dismiss the plaintiff was also significant and warranted quashing the penalty of dismissal.
(5) The court quashed the decision that the plaintiff was guilty of a disciplinary offence and the decision that he be dismissed, and ordered that he be reinstated as a member of the Police Force and paid back-pay.
Cases cited:
Clement Kilepak v Ellison Kaivovo (2003) N2402; George Kakas v Commissioner of Police, SCM No 17 of 2005, 29.07.07; Gideon Barereba v Margaret Elias (2002) N2197; Jeffrey Afozah v Commissioner of Police, Police Department and The State, OS No 330 of 2002, 26.02.04; Jeffrey Afozah v Commissioner of Police, Police Department and The State, SCM No 2 of 2004, 01.09.06; John Magaidimo v Commissioner of Police (2004) N2752; Kita Sapu v Commissioner of Police (2003) N2426; Mision Asiki v Manasupe Zurenuoc, Morobe Provincial Administration and The State (2005) SC797; Morobe Provincial Government v Minister for Village Services (1994) N1215; Mudge v Secretary for Lands and Others [1985] PNGLR 387; Paul Pora v Commissioner of Police (1997) N1569; Paul Saboko v Commissioner of Police (2006) N2975; Peter Bon v Mark Nakgai (2001) PNGLR 18; Peter Luga v Richard Sikani (2002) N2285; United States of America v WR Carpenters (Properties) Ltd [1992] PNGLR 185
JUDICIAL REVIEW
This was an application for judicial review of the decisions of the Commissioner of Police to find the plaintiff guilty of a disciplinary offence and to dismiss him from the Police Force.
7 April, 2008
1 CANNINGS J: This is a ruling on an application for judicial review of the decisions of the Commissioner of Police to find the plaintiff, Jeffrey Afozah, guilty of a disciplinary offence and to dismiss him from the Police Force.
2 Mr Afozah passed out of Bomana Police College and became a member of the Royal Papua New Guinea Constabulary (the Police Force) in 1986. He was posted to Kimbe police station, West New Britain. He was promoted to Senior Constable in 1992. He was stationed at Kimbe until his dismissal from the Force. On 18 July 1998 he was charged with a disciplinary offence: being AWAL (absent from duty without authorised leave) for a period of three months and ten days, from 27 March to 6 July 1998.
3 The Commissioner of Police found him guilty and imposed the penalty of dismissal. Those decisions were conveyed to the plaintiff by an undated ‘notice of penalty of serious disciplinary offence’ served on him on 28 February 2001. He had been taken off the payroll on 26 September 2000.
GROUNDS OF REVIEW
4 Mr Afozah is challenging...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Jacob Sanga Kumbu v Dr Nicholas Mann, Chairman, Council Appeal Committee, University of Papua New Guinea and University of Papua New Guinea and The Independent State of Papua New Guinea (2012) N4746
...Namaliu (No 1) [1995] PNGLR 481; Island Helicopter Services Ltd v Wilson Sagati (2008) N3340; Jeffrey Afozah v The Police Commissioner (2008) N3300; John Mua Nilkare v Ombudsman Commission [1996] PNGLR 333; John Unido v Sam Inguba, Commissioner of Police (2008) N3369; Wilson Kamit v Aus-PNG......
-
Lelesi Aiyango v Honk Kiap—The Chairman National Capital, District Commission, Staff Appeals Tribunal and Leslie Alu, The Manager, National Capital District Commission and National Capital District Commission and The Independent State of Papua New Guinea (2012) N4651
...Elias (2002) N2197; Gulf Provincial Government v Baimuru Trading Pty Ltd [1998] PNGLR 311; Jeffrey Afozah v The Police Commissioner (2008) N3300; John Magaidimo v Commissioner for Police (2004) N2752; Mision Asiki v Manasupe Zurenuoc (2005) SC797; Paul Saboko v Commissioner of Police (2006)......
-
Dale Christopher Smith v Minister for Lands and The Independent State of Papua New Guinea and NCD Water & Sewerage Limited Trading as Eda Ranu (2009) SC973
...v Sir Michael Somare (2008) N3476 Island Helicopter Services Ltd v Wilson Sagati (2008) N3340 Jeffrey Afozah v The Police Commissioner (2008) N3300 John Joe Nemambo v Peter Peipul (1994) SC475 Koitachi Ltd v Walter Schnaubelt (2007) SC870 Mision Asiki v Manasupe Zurenuoc (2005) SC797 Nancy ......
-
Gerry Harou and Payang Ete v John Solok, Executive Manager, Customer Services, PNG Waterboard and PNG Waterboard (2009) N3929
...are cited in the judgment: George Kakas v Commissioner of Police, SCM No 17 of 2005, 29.07.07; Jeffrey Afozah v The Police Commissioner (2008) N3300; Kita Sapu v The Commissioner of Police (2003) N2426; Mision Asiki v Manasupe Zurenuoc (2005) SC797; Paul Saboko v Commissioner of Police (200......
-
Jacob Sanga Kumbu v Dr Nicholas Mann, Chairman, Council Appeal Committee, University of Papua New Guinea and University of Papua New Guinea and The Independent State of Papua New Guinea (2012) N4746
...Namaliu (No 1) [1995] PNGLR 481; Island Helicopter Services Ltd v Wilson Sagati (2008) N3340; Jeffrey Afozah v The Police Commissioner (2008) N3300; John Mua Nilkare v Ombudsman Commission [1996] PNGLR 333; John Unido v Sam Inguba, Commissioner of Police (2008) N3369; Wilson Kamit v Aus-PNG......
-
Lelesi Aiyango v Honk Kiap—The Chairman National Capital, District Commission, Staff Appeals Tribunal and Leslie Alu, The Manager, National Capital District Commission and National Capital District Commission and The Independent State of Papua New Guinea (2012) N4651
...Elias (2002) N2197; Gulf Provincial Government v Baimuru Trading Pty Ltd [1998] PNGLR 311; Jeffrey Afozah v The Police Commissioner (2008) N3300; John Magaidimo v Commissioner for Police (2004) N2752; Mision Asiki v Manasupe Zurenuoc (2005) SC797; Paul Saboko v Commissioner of Police (2006)......
-
Dale Christopher Smith v Minister for Lands and The Independent State of Papua New Guinea and NCD Water & Sewerage Limited Trading as Eda Ranu (2009) SC973
...v Sir Michael Somare (2008) N3476 Island Helicopter Services Ltd v Wilson Sagati (2008) N3340 Jeffrey Afozah v The Police Commissioner (2008) N3300 John Joe Nemambo v Peter Peipul (1994) SC475 Koitachi Ltd v Walter Schnaubelt (2007) SC870 Mision Asiki v Manasupe Zurenuoc (2005) SC797 Nancy ......
-
Gerry Harou and Payang Ete v John Solok, Executive Manager, Customer Services, PNG Waterboard and PNG Waterboard (2009) N3929
...are cited in the judgment: George Kakas v Commissioner of Police, SCM No 17 of 2005, 29.07.07; Jeffrey Afozah v The Police Commissioner (2008) N3300; Kita Sapu v The Commissioner of Police (2003) N2426; Mision Asiki v Manasupe Zurenuoc (2005) SC797; Paul Saboko v Commissioner of Police (200......