The Independent State of Papua New Guinea and Sam Akoita, Minister for Mines and Tolukuma Gold Mines Limited v Central Provincial Government (2009) SC977
Jurisdiction | Papua New Guinea |
Date | 15 June 2009 |
Citation | (2009) SC977 |
Docket Number | SCA 99 &100 OF 2005 |
Court | Supreme Court |
Year | 2009 |
Full Title: SCA 99 &100 OF 2005; The Independent State of Papua New Guinea and Sam Akoita, Minister for Mines and Tolukuma Gold Mines Limited v Central Provincial Government (2009) SC977
Supreme Court: Sakora, Manuhu & Hartshorn JJ
Judgment Delivered: 15 June 2009
APPEAL - Appeal against refusal to dismiss Originating Summons as an abuse of process—whether trial judge erred in his determination of whether correct procedure used in claiming relief sought—application for declaratory orders—factors necessary for relief to be sought—no competing rights or controversy between parties—abuse of process - appeal upheld
Facts:
Tolukuma Gold Mines Ltd operates a mine in the Central Province and was granted an extension of the term of its mining lease. The Central Provincial Government (CPG) sought declaratory relief in the National Court that the extension was unconstitutional, unlawful and null and void. Tolukuma applied unsuccessfully to dismiss the National Court proceeding as being incompetent and an abuse of process. Tolukuma, the State and the Minister for Mines appeal that decision refusing to dismiss.
Held:
1. There is no requirement for the Central Provincial Government to be consulted before the term of a mining lease is extended. There are no competing rights or controversy between the parties and declaratory relief should not have been sought.
2. CPG’s cause of action is incontestably bad and an abuse of process.
3. The trial judge fell into error when he exercised his discretion and refused to dismiss the proceeding as an abuse of process under O12 r40(1)(c) National Court Rules.
4. The appeal is upheld and the whole of the interlocutory judgment of the National Court of 3rd August 2005 is set aside.
Cases cited:
Papua New Guinea cases:
Donigi v The State [1991] PNGLR 376; Curtain Bros (PNG) Ltd v UPNG (2005) SC788; Ok Tedi Mining Ltd v Niugini Insurance Corporation (No 2) [1988–89] PNGLR 425
Overseas Cases:
Ainsworth v. Criminal Justice Commission (1991-1992) 175 CLR 564; Mentha & Ors v. GE Capital Ltd & Anor (1997) 154 ALR 565; Russian Commercial and Industrial Bank v. British Bank for Foreign Trade Ltd [1921] 2 AC 438
15 June, 2009
1. BY THE COURT: Tolukuma Gold Mines Ltd operates a mine in the Central Province and was granted an extension of the term of its mining lease. The Central Provincial Government (CPG) sought declaratory relief in the National Court that the extension was unconstitutional, unlawful and null and void. Tolukuma applied unsuccessfully to dismiss the National Court proceeding as being incompetent and an abuse of process. Tolukuma, the State...
To continue reading
Request your trial-
Ramu Nico Management (MCC) Limited and Mineral Resources Authority and Dr Wari Iamo In His Capacity as the Director of the Environment and Department of Environment and Conservation and The Independent State of Papua New Guinea v Eddie Tarsie for himself and in his capacity as Ward Councillor of Ward 3, Sidor LLG and Farina Siga for himself and in his capacity as Ward Secretary of Ward 3, Sidor, LLG and Peter Sel and Pommern Incorporated Land Group No 12591 and Sama Melambo for himself and as Chairman of Pommern Incorporated Land Group (2010) SC1075
...New Guinea and Brigadier Leo Nuia OBE; Brigadier General Jerry Singirok MBE v NEC (1997) N1590; The State v Central Provincial Government (2009) SC977; Stettin Bay Lumber Company Pty Ltd v Arya Ship Management Ltd (1995) SC488; Southern Highlands Provincial Government v NHC (2001) N2110; Th......
-
Amos Ere v National Housing Corporation
...v. Maurice Alaluku, Secretary Department of Lands [2000] PNGLR 392 Independent State of Papua New Guinea v. Central Provincial Government (2009) SC977 Kiee Toap v. The State (2004) N2731, N2766 Kerry Lerro v. Stagg (2006) N3050 Louis Medaing v. Ramu Nico Management (MCC) Ltd (2010) N4158 Mi......
-
Isaac Lupari v Sir Michael Somare, MP—Prime Minister & Chairman of the National Executive Council and Rigo Lua—Chairman Of Public Service Commission and The Independent State of Papua New Guinea (2010) SC1071
...v Casper Wallace (2010) SC1016; Dr Rose Kekedo v Burns Philp (PNG) Ltd [1988–89] PNGLR 122; The State v Central Provincial Government (2009) SC977; Tolom Abai v The State (2000) SC632; Young Wedau v PNG Habours Board [1995] PNGLR 357 Overseas Cases Ball v Coggs (1710) 1 Bro Parl Case 140; C......
-
Waigani Heights Development Ltd v Benjamin Mul
...[1990] PNGLR 278 Dr. Onne Rageau v. Kina Finance Ltd (2015) N6175 Independent State of Papua New Guinea v. Central Provincial Government (2009) SC977 Kerry Lerro v. Stagg & Ors (2006) N3050 Mt Hagen Urban Local Level Government v. Sek No. 15 (2009) SC1007 National Capital District Interim C......
-
Amos Ere v National Housing Corporation
...v. Maurice Alaluku, Secretary Department of Lands [2000] PNGLR 392 Independent State of Papua New Guinea v. Central Provincial Government (2009) SC977 Kiee Toap v. The State (2004) N2731, N2766 Kerry Lerro v. Stagg (2006) N3050 Louis Medaing v. Ramu Nico Management (MCC) Ltd (2010) N4158 Mi......
-
Ramu Nico Management (MCC) Limited and Mineral Resources Authority and Dr Wari Iamo In His Capacity as the Director of the Environment and Department of Environment and Conservation and The Independent State of Papua New Guinea v Eddie Tarsie for himself and in his capacity as Ward Councillor of Ward 3, Sidor LLG and Farina Siga for himself and in his capacity as Ward Secretary of Ward 3, Sidor, LLG and Peter Sel and Pommern Incorporated Land Group No 12591 and Sama Melambo for himself and as Chairman of Pommern Incorporated Land Group (2010) SC1075
...New Guinea and Brigadier Leo Nuia OBE; Brigadier General Jerry Singirok MBE v NEC (1997) N1590; The State v Central Provincial Government (2009) SC977; Stettin Bay Lumber Company Pty Ltd v Arya Ship Management Ltd (1995) SC488; Southern Highlands Provincial Government v NHC (2001) N2110; Th......
-
Isaac Lupari v Sir Michael Somare, MP—Prime Minister & Chairman of the National Executive Council and Rigo Lua—Chairman Of Public Service Commission and The Independent State of Papua New Guinea (2010) SC1071
...v Casper Wallace (2010) SC1016; Dr Rose Kekedo v Burns Philp (PNG) Ltd [1988–89] PNGLR 122; The State v Central Provincial Government (2009) SC977; Tolom Abai v The State (2000) SC632; Young Wedau v PNG Habours Board [1995] PNGLR 357 Overseas Cases Ball v Coggs (1710) 1 Bro Parl Case 140; C......
-
Waigani Heights Development Ltd v Benjamin Mul
...[1990] PNGLR 278 Dr. Onne Rageau v. Kina Finance Ltd (2015) N6175 Independent State of Papua New Guinea v. Central Provincial Government (2009) SC977 Kerry Lerro v. Stagg & Ors (2006) N3050 Mt Hagen Urban Local Level Government v. Sek No. 15 (2009) SC1007 National Capital District Interim C......